52 Comments This discussion is locked.
how do you tell the difference between "il mange" and "ils mangent"?? cuz you don't pronounce the "ent" in mangent or the "s" in ils
You have to rely on the context they are said in, but this one is rather ambiguous.
Yeah, I had il mange and it still got accepted, so I guess the ambiguity is supported by the app!
i had il mange and it got accepted as well. But there is a big difference between il mange and ils mangent. Is there any way to spot the difference ??
I suppose that because there is no verbal difference, in real life you would rely on the context.
But, there being no context here, Duo accepts both.
I also understood il mange. It wasn't accepted but I listened 3 times to hear the s' s and the only one I heard was from the 'les'
I just put everything in plural because this is the plurals module, so I got it right, but I couldn't hear any difference.
Of course it's like that! Try to translate from ENG something like YOU ARE PRETTY: how'd you think it's correct? Tu es joli, tu es jolie, vous etez joli, or vous etez jolie? All of them at the same time, you can't say the difference from that small sentence in English.
"Il mange" means "he eats/he is eating". It's singular, but when pronouncing it, you just have to listen to the sentence and the context.
Tom they are silent but on reading you understand which gender and adjectives used
It's really tough to tell when it's »le« or »les« I guess »le« is more like »luhhh« and les is »l-ehh«?
Tell me please How do I know when I hear the sentence if it's mean "he eats..." or "they eat..." ??
Think of les as lay and la as lah. I saw someone else say that on another discussion and it helped me a lot!!
I think crêpe is feminine, so you can tell by that (it would be LA, not LE, if it was singular).
Try to pay close attention to the way the sentence is worded, this helps me most of the time.
in this case you could respond in two ways: 1. 'il mange les crepes' and you would be correct because 'He is eating crepes'. 2. ils mangent les crepes' and you would still be correct because 'They are eating crepes'. however if you get the conjugation wrong or the plurals wrong, or you mix up the persons you will get an incorrect response. e.g. if you wrote 'il mangent les crepes' or 'ils mange les crepes' or 'il mange le crepe' it would all be wrong for various reasons. Key thing is to listen to the 'le' vs 'les' that will tell you the plurality and then match up the person and the verb correctly.
il/ils; mange/mangent; le/les; crêpe/crêpes. Everything sounds alike for me, since there is no "liasson" or anything :(
il mange vs ils mangent = you are right
le/les crêpes: this is not right, because the singular of "les crêpes" is la crêpe (fem), so you should hear a difference between sound A and sound EH
Le and les are pronounced differently. Based on this you know whether there is a singular or plural next to le/les
Noted in passing: Whereas Duo's spelling of 'crepe' in English is probably correct for American English, the Oxford English Dictionary only lists 'crêpe' as the correct spelling.
I am a little confused why in this case we use "ils mangent les crêpes" and not "ils mangent des crêpes"...
"ils mangent les crêpes" is "they eat the crepes" and "ils mangent des crêpes" is "they eat (some) crepes". It's just a difference between any crepes or specific crepes. Hope that helps!
Does anyone else come from somewhere where crêpes has the circumflex? Around here crepes is a spelling error in English!
Why do you have to say "Ils mangent des pommes", but you can't say "Ils mangent des crêpes"? Sorry for the ignorance, but I just don't get it.
this was another example of the singular and plural sounding alike (I chose plural because of receiving a correction for the singular choice in a different question -- seems when in doubt this program goes for plural?) but also, the les sounded just like a le to me. Maybe it's the sound quality of my headphones but I replayed it repeatedly and it always sounds like le even though I know it is les.
It helps to realize that this is in the plural section of the French lessons.
are we all just gonna ignore the fact that it says "crepes" means backcombs...
No, the hint reads "(you) backcomb/are backcombing", which shows that this is (also) a verb.
could you tecnically not use the word SOME instead of THE? To me it sounds better saying "They some are eating some crepes" versus saying "they are eating the crepes"
No, because "some" translates "des, un certain nombre de", not "les".
You have to understand that "les" really means "the", as specific crepes, already mentioned in the conversation, for ex.
I spoke a different sentence and it gave me correct! I thought my pronunciation was good until now! Is there a sequence of good & bad that it cycles through? To think i believed it was listening to my attempts!
- singular indefinite: une crêpe = a/one crepe
plural indefinite: des crêpes = crepes
singular definite: la crêpe = the crepe
- plural definite: les crêpes = the crepes
Don't hate me if I'm wrong, but it said that when the letter "C" is in front of vowels, it is pronounced as a hard "K", but here it is in front of the letter R, and it is pronounced as a hard K, can someone please explain this to me.
C has a K hard sound in front of consonants and 'hard' vowels = a, o, u: canard, copain, cube
C has a S soft sound in front of 'soft' vowels: e, i, y = ceci, cycle
"CH" followed by a vowel sounds like "sh" = chien
"CH" followed by a consonant sounds like K = chrétien
OK, thank you, I guess I didn't really read that correctly, again thanks for clearing that up.
I typed "They eat crepes" but wouldnt this need to be: "Ils mangent des crepes". My general rule is les is referring to an 'exact amount' while des is refering to an undefined amount.
"they eat crepes" is the plural of "they eat a/one crepe".
In French: des crêpes is the plural of une crêpe.
English does not have a plural indefinite article, but "des" is required in French.