"Ĉu vi iam vidis vulkanon?"

Translation: Have you ever seen a volcano?

[Cal-H]

Jes, en Japanio.

[farl_]

Jes! Mi eĉ ĵetis ringon en ĝin!

[KevinM676685]

Bedauxras pri vian fingron

[jim3cantos]

Fumanta vulkanon, ne.

[hellomidnight]

Jes! Mi staris sur la rando, kaj rigardis la internaĵo!

[robot-dreams]

... ial mi skribis "Did you ever see a volcanon?"

[TreyEHarris]

“Had you ever seen a volcano?” was marked wrong. My understanding was that the Esperanto past tense encompasses the simple past and the past perfect, though if you want to be specific you can say Ĉu vi iam estis vidinta vulkanon?

I submitted this answer, but if it’s just wrong for some reason, I’d like to understand my flub.

[RandomCanadian12]

hmmm. Fakte ne

[BossLearner87]

Have you ever seen a volcano is more natural. That sounds like 1 very specific volcano

[PurpleHuedMagPie]

English being my birth language, and I got the English wrong too many times to count :/

have/had
seen/saw

[CharlesDanielChr]

"Did you, at some time, see a volcano?" was counted wrong. Is there a significant difference between the two translation that I am failing to see?