"Juice is not food, but a drink."
Translation:Suko ne estas manĝaĵo, sed trinkaĵo.
16 CommentsThis discussion is locked.
What is the difference between manĝo and manĝaĵo? As well as between trinko and trinkaĵo?
The -aĵ suffix means the root is a substance.
thing (concrete idea), a concrete manifestation of an abstraction, the external manifestation of an activity, a characteristic piece of behaviour, the flesh of an animal, product, dish
-- http://www.molossia.org/esperantoaffix.html
manĝo is meal as in the slightly abstracted notion like breakfast, lunch, or dinner.
manĝaĵo is food as in a particular edible.
A meal/manĝo is made out of food/manĝaĵo.
Trinko vs trinkaĵo is harder to pin down, but if follows the same idea.
Does anyone else want "Suko ne estas manĝaĵo, sed sandviĉo" on a shirt? Oh the sentences and answers in this course, LOL. Via urso trinkas bieron!
774
Se la urso estas esperantisto, verŝajne ankaŭ ĝi drinkas bieron, krom se ĝi estas baha-ano, tiam ĝi bierumas supozeble nur sekrete … (cetere ĉu vi konas la diferencon inter drinki kaj trinki? …)
Ne, I have yet to learn the difference between the infinitives "trinki" kaj "drinki". Is "drinki" similar "to drink (alcohol)" in English? "Via urso trinkas bieron" was another funny sentence from another lesson, haha.
- 774
in this context just "manĝo" is exact enough. The answer "suko ne estas manĝo, sed trinkaĵo" should also be accepted: I remark that the "duolingo" test is to strict and cannot recognize most of possible correct answers ..
- 774
Effectively many other correct answers have been added to the database in the meantime! So the app became much better now! Thanks and congratulation for the team!
Yes.
ĵ is like "zh" (/ʒ/) as in the English "measure"
ĝ is like "j" (/dʒ/) as in the English "judge"
And of course j is like "y" (/j/) as in the English "yo-yo" and g is like "g" (/g/) as in the English "go".
In the English sentence "food" is a collective (e.g. plural) noun; shouldn't the Esperanto equivalent be "manĝaĵoj"?