1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: Turkish
  4. >
  5. "I want to read a book when i…

"I want to read a book when it rains."

Translation:Yağmur yağdığı zaman kitap okumak istiyorum.

September 23, 2015



what about 'Yağmur yağdığında....' ..?


It is accepted


Why not yağıken?


*'Yağmur yağarken' is a perfectly valid form....but the -dık form is more commonly used.


I the suffix -ı in "yağdığı" a posessive suffix? If it is, then "yağmur yağdığı zaman" can be literaly translated as "the time of its raining."


" the time of raining " or " the raining time " there is no "its" here.


Why do you not use the accusative here for 'okumak' according to 'istiyorum', please? (okumayı)


Would yağmur yağdıkta be incorrect?


I think it is incorrect because yağdıkta has no possessive ending. The "possessor" is yağmur (even if it is not in the genitive case), and the posessive ending should precede the locative ending: yağdığında.


is there any way to express this using yağ(?)-nce instead of yağ-dığında?


Not really here. Using the suffix -(y)IncA implies that the action ends and then the second one starts. It would be like saying "I want to read a book once it rains."


I would oppose that. I think -(y)Inca is fine (exactly the same as -dIğIndA except that it's subjectless) and it doesn't necessarily mean that the action ends. Once actually would translate to these three forms.

Yağmur yağdı mı kitap okumak istiyorum.
Yağmur yağar yağmaz kitap okumak istiyorum.
Yağmur yağdığı anda kitap okumak istiyorum

And these forms in Turkish and once in English don't suggest that the first action has finished before the second action but it suggests that the second action started immediately after the first action.


I haven't seen the first model before. ("Yağmur yağdı kitap okumak istiyorum.") I didn't know that "mı" could be used in this way. I have only seen it in questions. It seems to say: Did it rain? I want to read a book. Or: If it rained, I want to read a book.


That's not what 'once it rains' means.


"Yağmur yağarken bir kitap okumak istiyorum" neden yanlış? lütfen bana yardım ederiz




"I want to read a book when it rains." Translation: Yağmur yağdığı zaman kitap okumak istiyorum.

"Yağmur yağarken bir kitap okumak istiyorum" neden yanlış? lütfen bana yardım ederiz

I can explain in English & a little Turkish:

"Yağmur yağdığı zaman" - When it rains. Sadece yağmur başlarken, kitap okumak istiyorum. - Only when it starts to rain/is raining is more accurate in English.

"Yağmur yağarken" - While it rains.

"Yağmur yağarken kitap okumak istiyorum. - I want to read a book while it rains.

(y) -ken suffix - "while."

There is a subtle difference between the two.

Şimdi anladın mı? - Do you understand now?

Teşekkür ederim.


Thank you for the explanation. It means that yagiyorken/yagarken should be accepted as translations.


Would "Yağmur yağdığında kitap okumak istiyorum" be acceptable?




"I want to read a book when it rains." - Yağmur yağdığı zaman kitap okumak istiyorum.

Would "Yağmur yağdığında kitap okumak istiyorum" be acceptable? - I'm saying yes.

Did you use the "free Turkish contextual dictionary?" Many of their definitions/entries are wrong.

Thank you.


Thank you MrHilmiNevzat

No I wasn't using that dictionary, I was just trying to apply what I learnt in the "-DIk" skill, where the use of the "-DIk" form with the locative "-DA" was equivalent to a "when" phrase.

In fact, it's not clear to me why this particular example favours a phrase with "zaman". Is it just another way of saying it? Is it idiomatically more common? . . .




"Yağmur yağdığı zaman" - "the time of raining" & "when in rains."

The definition of "time" (zaman) here is abstract & its duration cannot be really determined. I think it should remain in the Turkish answer.

Yağmur yağdığı zaman televızyona bakarum. - When it rains I watch the television.

Yağmur yağdığı zaman seninle konuşmayı severim. - When it rains I like talking with you.

In the two examples "zaman" is more natural to remain in the sentence. " idiomatically more common? . . ."

Thank you for your reply & I will revise the "-DIk" skill.


Çok teşekkürler. Çok ilginç. I wonder if, tentatively, one can say that -DIk + -DA form is rather used for actions, and the -DIk + zaman form is more for events... I'll have to watch/listen for it.



Rica ederim! - You're welcome!


"I want to read a book when it rains." Translation: Yağmur yağdığı zaman kitap okumak istiyorum.


Yağmur yağdığında kitap okumak istiyorum.

Correct other Turkish answer accepted by Duo.

Learn Turkish in just 5 minutes a day. For free.