- Forum >
- Topic: German >
- "Die Geschwister mögen die Är…
"Die Geschwister mögen die Ärzte nicht."
Translation:The siblings do not like the doctors.
44 Comments
Is there a lesson about articles here? "Die Ärzte" is translated as simply "doctors."
It should be “the doctors”. Please report it using the ‘Report a Problem’ button.
It sounds to me like the female voice is saying "Artze" rather than "Ärtze" which makes it a bit confusing when given a listening exercise.
Yes, but Arzte is not a word as far as I know, so I found that listening to the slow version helped clear up why that -e was on the end. Once I knew it was Ärzte I could almost convince myself the fast version was OK too but I think it might be a bit off, especially when you compare it to native speakers in the following:
so the siblings do not like doctors in general? seems like the sentence said they don't like a particular set of doctors.
Correct. “The siblings do not like doctors.” would just be ‘Die Geschwister mögen Ärzte nicht,’, or, more commonly, ‘Die Geschwister mögen keine Ärzte.’ Please report it.
‘Die Geschwister mögen keine Ärzte.’ literally means “The siblings don't like any doctors.”, so although it's more idiomatic, it's technically less correct.
I am confused...( nicht ) should be before definite noun why it comes at the last of the sentence?
780
Perhaps the following article will help you. nicht is supposed to follow a noun with a definite article which is being negated.
A predicative noun provides more information about the SUBJECT in the sentence. Ex.- My dog is my best friend. "Friend" is the predicate noun here as it tell more about the subject "my dog". In this case, "Geschwister", not "die Ärzte" is the subject while "die Arzte" is simply the direct object identifying whom the subject doesn't like.
- 19
wouldn't the siblings don't like the (female) doctor (singular) sound the same as this? And so shouldn't it be accepted bc we only hear it?
How come "The siblings" translate as Die Geschwister and not Die Geschwistern?
The singular is "das Geschwister". It's only used in academia (sociology, psychology, etc.), though. The plural is "die Geschwister".
Geschwistern would be the dativ case (e.g. when using "mit" den Geschwistern or "zu" den Geschwistern). in the Nominativ it's simply "die Geschwister".
OK, I'm really confused about the placement on "nicht". On the very last sentence I did, "Ich will zum Arzt nicht" was corrected to "Ich will nicht zum Arzt", suggesting that "nicht" has to immediately follow the verb, but here the official answer places it at the end of the sentence. What gives?
- 780
This is not to answer your question but I have noticed that quite of lot of exercises put 'nicht' at the end of sentences whenever the verb 'mag' is used. Not sure if it is always the case.
No it comes always before prepositions read this https://deutsch.lingolia.com/en/grammar/sentence-structure/negation
The spoken version with a male voice speaks far too quickly and can't be slowed down :(
- 194
This may be a referral to the German band "Die Ärzte", although the D should be capitalized.
That would mean they don't like any doctors; the sentence above refers to specific doctors.
i can't help with all the professional terminology, but the difference is the verb. in the sentence "ich will nicht zum Arzt" the "will" is an auxiliary, with the main verb, "gehen" only implied (a specialty of the German language). the "nicht" will always follow the auxiliary directly. ich kann nicht höher springen ich will nicht mitmachen ich darf nicht rauchen ich soll nicht zu fremden Leuten ins Auto steigen. in the sentence here you have a simple verb which gets negated at the sentence end. sie mögen die Ärzte (nicht) sie hören das Telefon (nicht) ich mag Rockmusik (nicht)
- 464
"Die Ärzte nicht" sounds almost the same as "die Ärztin nicht" unless you're listening on slow, which I only do if I'm having trouble on regular speed. :-P
Exactly. I had the same problem. The two versions sound almost identical.
Okay fine no bad jokes about twins. Of course they don't like doctors.
I have written "die aerzte", it was accepted but it says I have a typo. In the rest of Duolingo it accepts ae as ä and does not make a difference, so I see an inconsistency here.
That has a different meaning. In your sentence, the siblings don't just dislike the doctors we were talking about. They don't like any doctors.
