1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: German
  4. >
  5. "Er kommt aus Deutschland."

"Er kommt aus Deutschland."

Translation:He comes from Germany.

October 12, 2015



I answered "He comes from Germany" and its came up wrong and the correct answer is "He hails from Germany" ???


Me too, answer the same thing. And it came up wrong. But this is right too.


Is it just me, or does Deutschland literally mean German Land?


You are correct! Deutsch = German Land = Country


Sounds more like "Ihr kommt" rather than "Er kommt". I was lead to believe that "Ihr" sounds like english "Ear" and "Er" is like "pear". This one definitely has an [i] sound to it.


"Ihr" is usually pronounced "Ear" and "Er" is usually pronounced "Aire" (or at least that is how I say it and I haven't been told not to yet)


I thought so, too. Luckily, a little bit later in this lesson, I ran into a sentence that DID have "Ihr" in it and it had an even more obvious "Ear" sound to it.

I think you're exactly right about the "ear" and "pear" comparison. You'll be able to tell the difference in no time!


That's what I heard too. I put that and it was wrong. I can usually hear the difference but this time it really sounded like "Ihr" not "Er".


The voice (at least the female one) clearly says ‘er’. The ‘ear’ vs ‘air’ distinction is really flawed to begin with: both ‘er’ and ‘ihr’ have long vowel sounds, that more readily correspond to English ‘ay’ (imagine a Scotsman saying that) and ‘ee’. The problem is that when English puts ‘r’ after those sounds they generally change to a short ‘eh’ (like ‘pet’) and ‘ih’ (like ‘pit’) sound respectively, which doesn't happen in German. I think the best way to approach the pronunciation of ‘er’ and ‘ihr’ for an English speaker is to first think about the vowels and then simply append a short ‘ah’ or ‘uh’ kind of sound at the end. As you can see, that is clearly different from the pronunciations of ‘ear’ and ‘air’.


In English, "coming from" can mean where someone grew up, ("I came from Chicago") and it also can mean where someone was previously ("where did you come from?" "I came from the kitchen."), are both of those meanings also contained in kommt?


So Germany is German isn't called Germany? And is Deutschland the german name of Germany?


And is it not right: "He is from Germany " instead of "He comes from Germany" ?


I'm having trouble pronouncing 'Deutschland' properly. Is it 'Doych-land' or 'Doytsch-shland.' lol idk


Mainly Doytsch-land


I say dodge-land with a bit of a t sound at dg


what is the difference between "kommt" & "kömmt"? they are listed in the conjugate area.


"kömmt" is an old form of the third person singular (kommt), like "cometh" would be in English, but it isn't used any more, except in some dialects.


I hesitated before i could say it and it graded it as right should i be concerned? Lol


Likewise. Replayed it 20 times to make sure but I'm not going say it.


I am a little confused by the exact meaning of the German phrase. Does it mean "He comes from Germany" as in that is where he hails from, or does it just mean he is coming from Germany (as in traveling)? Or is it just as ambiguous in German as it is in English?


It's ambiguous, but most often would be understand as indicating national origin, regardless of any movement involved -- for example, I might say that "I come from Germany" even if I'm currently in Germany, but am identifying my origin on an international message board.


What is the meaning of the word "aus" separately???


"From", but especially in the sense of "out of, from within"—otherwise you'd use "von". Another meaning is also "made of", as in "die Murmel ist aus Glas" = "the marble is made of glass".


Why not "He comes from Deutschland " ? Should we translate verbatim ?


Because "Deutschland" isn't an English word. I don't say I come from Italia when I'm speaking English, nor do you say "vengo dall'England" when speaking Italian, so you shouldn't really say "I come from Deutschland" but rather "I come from Germany".
Also, how would Duo know that you know what "Deutschland" means if you don't translate it?


Does "Er" only stand for "He"?


"He is coming from Germany" accepted


Not for me. It is refused.


It is very difficult for me to pronounce 'Deutschland'. Is there any website,to clear this problem?


So how do you actually get progress past this part? What is the accepted phrase?


What is maen hails ?


“to hail from” is a verb used in formal speech meaning “to come from” (said of a person). It's not often used in everyday speech.

Also, if I may, the auxiliary verb for questions and negations in English is “to do”, so your question would have been better phrased: “what does 'hails' mean?”.


I do not understand when I put down " He came from Germany " is wrong, when that's how people say it.


‘Came’ is past tense; it would be correct, for example, when referring to someone who's passed away. The present conjugation has to be ‘he comes’.


As a native English speaker I believe I could use the pronoun 'they' in the case on masculine, singular.


In general, I'd say yes, but since it's a translation exercise meant to probe your knowledge of German, it's better to stick to literal translations of pronouns (although it is true that German has no gender neutral option, so, depending on the translator, ‘er’ could be translated with they in certain contexts).


I do not understand when should I use - He comes from Germany or He is from Germany. Fisrt, the because the meaning is the same and second because two questions ago I missed because was "Sie Kommt aus Deuschland" and Duolingo said that the correct answer was "She comes from England", when I answered the first one.

Conclusion - same sentence, only change the person and one is correct, one is wrong.


Sometimes some valid alternatives for certain exercises are missing because the curators are only human and cannot always think of all possible alternatives. As you say, ‘to come from’ and ‘to be from’ mean the same thing and they are interchangeable (and are so treated in the course), so when one of the two options is not accepted you should report it.


"He is from Germany" was accepted. Hope this is of some help.



Can we write this statement like this "Er kommst aus Deutschland "


Can we write this statement like this "Er kommst aus Deutschland "

No. The verb ending -st is for du, not for er.

er takes verbs ending in -t, such as er kommt.


He comes from Germany or he is from germany ?


He comes from Germany or he is from germany ?

That's right; you can use either of those.


If I say "Er ist aus Deutschland" He is from Germany is it correct


Voice recognition isnt working, all setting correct on my phone.


i dont understand this question, example theres a question er kommt aus deutschland and i answer he comes from deutschland (incorrect) but there a question which means we come from germany and i answer we come from deutschland, it also incorrect. so somebody would you mind explain about this?


Youre putting english and german together


Deutschland is German for Germany. You need to translate it to "Germany."


It should be "he comes from germany" lol


How is "kommt" pronounced? I say it like "compt" and it always says incorect but that's how it sounds.


It si pronounced like "commt" or "comt" as you like


Deutschland means Germany or the countries that speaks deutsch


i pretty sure it is just Germany


So would 'She comes from' be 'Sie kommt aus...' ?


That's right.


In English either Germany and Deutschland are used as country name and both are correct!


I'm sorry, but "Deutschland" really isn't an English word, and while you might use it informally for comical effect or similar, it certainly isn't the name of the country in English; only Germany is correct.


Only in English German communitys


Got this, and previous similar one correct, but marked as wrong both times. Glitch?


What is the difference between kommt and kommst?


er kommt (he comes), du kommst (you come)

ich komme -

du kommst -

er /sie /es / ihr kommt -

sie kommen


I typed in "He 'come' from Germany" and it corrected me and said "He 'hails' from Germany." I am confused...


English requires an -s appended at the end of third person singular verbs, so "he comes" is the correct form, "he come" is bad English.


How to differenate come and comes


Comes is used only when the subject is third person singular, so with he, she, it or another singular noun, e.g.:
"he comes from Germany, I come from Italy and they come from Spain."
"she comes here often, but I only come here rarely."
"a dog comes this way, two more dogs come after it".


Why is it kommt and not kommst?


Because the subject is “er”.

Ich komme, du kommst, er kommt.


Family can I still say he is from Germany


Why not "He is German"? It may not be the literal translation, but it is the one I think of.


Kommt being said on this app sounded more like a rude word. I replayed it 20 times and I'm not going to pronounce it like Duo does!!


Its the same voice of" Ihr kommt aus Deutschland "!!!! But how could i know the difference if he meant Er or Ihr..??? Only when i get wrong.


This sounds like a line from a love song


Why is "He is coming from Germany" wrong? Does the use of "aus" imply something else?


why "he is from germany" is true? I think it has to be "er ist aus deutschland"


Confused Some sentence means Kommt aus = is from and kommt aus = coming from , how can I supposed to understand that


He comes from Germany sounds wrong to me. Wouldn't it be "he is coming from Germany" or "he came from Germany"?


I think it could also be translated as "he is coming from Germany" Perhaps to make the meaning clearer in real life one would re-phrase? Say e.g. "he is German" or "he is flying from Germany"


'He is German' would be better translated as 'Er ist deutsch' (although, you would probably be better off saying 'Er is Deutscher', meaning 'He is a German). You could use the sentence to mean that he is flying in from Germany, but that would be better translated as 'Er fliegt aus Deutschland'. As for your first example, 'He is coming from Germany' would indeed be translated as 'Er kommt aus Deutschland.'


Or "he is from Germany?" - Anyone else get that?


That was my answer, and it worked.


I am a native American and "He comes from Germany" sounds perfectly natural to me. It means the same thing as "He is from Germany"

Learn German in just 5 minutes a day. For free.