1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: German
  4. >
  5. "Professor, eins wollte ich v…


"Professor, eins wollte ich von Ihnen noch hören."

January 7, 2013



It's very frustrating to get this sentence translated correctly. I am writing it down so that the next time around I know the exact wording... ;)


well, this sentence makes no sense. In the moment it is spoken out, it is present. So it should be "I still want". i did this sentence wrong several (3) times, as the combination of "still" and "wanted" breaks my brain. "I wanted to hear one thing from you, but now I still don't want it anymore". Zum Glück mussten wir es nicht noch einmal machen. ..


The best I can offer to help your brain, is that "still wanted" is not present in the moment it is spoken out....so to speak. Try this..."I kept pestering my girlfriend because I still wanted to go to the bar, despite her telling me that she was too tired." That's the only way I can see "still wanted" working. As for Duolingo's sentence, it is incomplete. If they added to it along the lines of my example sentence it might work. As it stands though, terrible sentence.


To be fair, such a formulation is not unusual in English (I couldn't say if this is the case in German). It is a polite form of address, such as can be formulated both in the past tense as well as in the conditional (or a combination of the two) in English where a sort of self-effacing play of temporality and modesty puts the fate of your desire/wish in the hands of the person addressed. A banal example would be -- Upon entering a hairdressers and confronting the person behind the counter who asks how they may help you, you might say: "I wanted to know whether I could get my hair cut this afternoon?" / "I was hoping to get my hair cut this afternoon." In both cases the past tense can be thought of as operating in[to] the present.


I don't understand why duolingo has this structured learning but then introduces past tense (and other concepts) without warning.


The sentence is really dificult, and the modal verb in past tense!!!


Sometimes the sentences in Duolingo are too abstract for a beginner's course. They should use more tangible sentences. The abstract sentences make it hard for the students to concentrate on the grammar they are supposed to learn on that module.


The way it's explained in English seems like an incomplete sentence...


Thanks for feedback on this sentence. It will get removed.


would like to concur with those saying this sentence is terrible


why doesn't "Professor, I still wanted to hear one from you." work? I wouldn't always translate "eins" as "one thing".


Duolingo you are very unforgiving!


This is my second attempt and I still got it wrong!

Learn German in just 5 minutes a day. For free.