"Нет, мы не готовим."

Translation:No, we do not cook.

November 6, 2015

This discussion is locked.


What is the relation between готовить and приготовить?


Готовить (imperfective verb) is for:

  • Cooking in general (I never cook rice = Я никогда не готовлю рис); or
  • The process of cooking (What are you doing? Cooking. Что ты делаешь? Готовлю).

Приготовить (perfective verb) means make something cooked.

  • I need to cook rice = Мне нужно приготовить рис.
  • Have you cooked your meal? = Ты приготовил еду?
  • Have a rest, I'll cook the dinner. = Отдохни, я приготовлю ужин.

Note that "приготовить", as a perfective verb, cannot be used in present tense. The forms that look similar to those of "готовить" in present tense, for "приготовить" are, in fact, future tense.

  • Он готовит = He is cooking.
  • Он приготовит = He will cook (have cooked).

Most Russian verbs are in pairs of perfective and imperfective.


Благодарю вас.


Couldn't this also be "No, we are not cooking"?


It could - as the answer to the question "Что вы там делаете? Еду готовите?" The full answer could be "Нет, мы не готовим, мы просто чай пьём"


Would it also mean We are not ready?


That would be "Мы не готовы".


I'm dumb, I forgot that готовим is a verb, so obviously ready would be an adjective in Russian готовы! :)


Ready / готовы is an adjective ;-)


Yes, I got that. I just didn't know what to call the word ready. It isn't really an adjective, it's more... an adverb or something. I corrected the mistake! :)


"ready" is an adjective. The verb приготовить has also a meaning "to get (something) ready" / "to prepare"


Shouldn't it be гото́вый in the singular or гото́вые in the plural? Why is the й/е missing?


"Готовы" is a short (plural) form of the adjective. Sometimes it is preferred to the full form.


So should I regard готовые and Готовы as synonyms? Are Готовы and Готовый pronounced the same? Does the ые -> ы shortening work for any "ый" adjective?


These are not exactly synonyms, rather forms of the same word. They are not pronounced the same, in "готовый" there is a "й" sound at the end.

Short forms are not used for every adjective. I'm not ready to provide you with a rule (being a native speaker, I just know what sounds right). Try searching "short adjectives in Russian" on Google.


Is there a particular problem with translating 'готовим' as 'prepare' in this context? Or is it just more contextually appropriate to say 'cook'.


No problem. Consider this dialog: "Вы готовите внука к школе?" "Нет, мы не готовим. Дети готовят". 'Are you preparing your grandson for school?' 'No, we aren't. Our children /His parents are.'


Oh my god what if I accidentally misunderstood готовите внука as 'cooking your grandson'?


How would on say 'We don't cook'?


Мы не готовим еду.


Does that only mean "No, we do not cook"? Can it also mean "No, we are not cooking"? If not, how would you say "No, we are not cooking"?


It surely can mean “No, we are not cooking, we are doing something else”.


how to say no we arent cooking?


«Нет, мы не готовим». Depending on the situation, this sentence may mean either “We don’t cook” or “We aren’t cooking”. And if you add something like «вот уже два месяца», it will turn into “No, we haven’t been cooking for two months”.


Does it also mean "No, we don't get ready"? Or "we do not prepare"?


The Russian for “we don’t get ready” and “we are not getting ready” is «мы не готовимся». The verb “prepare” can be translated as готовить only if it used as transitive verb (in other words, there has to be a direct object). Otherwise, the verb готовиться is used in translation.


Anyone else thinks it sound alot like he is saying мой I only picked up it was мы due to the word ending.


Is "we are not cooking"corect too?


Yes, it is, in an appropriate context.


So, in a previous exercise "Мы готовим суп." meant "We are making soup." But now "мы не готовим." can't mean "We're not making." Why?

Learn Russian in just 5 minutes a day. For free.