- Forum >
- Topic: Russian >
- "Сколько там девочек?"
20 Comments
In this example is it a specific location, how many girls are over there in that place? Or is this how you would ask in general, how many girls exist in the scenario?
1172
This refers to how many girls there are over in that place ("there"). Там is the "there" which contrasts to the "here" of здесь or тут. While the Russian version is clear, the English version of this sentence is unfortunately ambiguous, because we use "there" to mean both a literal там location and a general sense of existence.
- 149
(Russian learner here). General existence probably with есть: Сколько есть девочек?
Maybe a native speaker can explain.
I wrote "How many girls are there there", and it was marked wrong. Others have apparently done the same. See this conversation. I reported it.
Came here to ask that too... My guess is there as in that place. Hopefully someone can clarify!
- 309
This is a dumb question because in the english you might say how many are there, then an additional there to clarify the location, too, but this isn't accepted.
- 340
The first time around, I wrote ' how many girls are there there,' which is how I would say it in my native english. Since it was marked wrong (as was little girl), I just wrote what the course wants. ;{
Same here. I put "there" twice as it is the correct translation but it wasn't accepted. I am pretty sure there is a problem here...not there
Apostrophe is a way to write soft sign (ь) with the Latin script. Soft sign changes the pronounciation of the preceding consonant; л is «hard» l, /l/, while ль is «soft» l' sound, /lʲ/.
Compare the difference in pronounciation of some words:
Most consonants in Russian have a soft and hard pairs, e.g. кон / kon — конь / kon'.
In the past, ь was a very short i-like (or e-like) consonant, but it disappeared, changing the way consonants are pronounced. English doesn't have a notion of soft/hard consonants, so it might take some effort to understand them.
- 1793
Thank you for the in-depth explanation of the soft sign. I guess I need to review your sections on soft signs.
BTW, having the latin characters helps a lot getting a taste of the Russian language! Thanks for putting this course together.
It wasn’t me who put it — I'm just going through the forum answering the questions (it makes me happy that people learn my native language), but the course was created by people like Shady_Arc.
- 1793
My bad! Thanks for taking the time to answer my basic question! The level of detail was appreciated as I do have an understanding of soft/hard sounds from other languages.
Why not "How many girls?" There are many contexts in which that is perfectly natural.
Is 'там' in this sentence meaning 'there' as in position or 'there' as in 'exists' / more figurative if you get me
