"We are strolling in the forest."

Translation:Мы гуляем в лесу.

November 22, 2015

26 Comments


https://www.duolingo.com/profile/madam_im_adam

does мы гуляем в лесе work here? if so, what would the difference between the two meanings be?

December 10, 2015

[deactivated user]

    No, it won't. A limited number of nouns has 2 prepositional case: normal prepositional case used after «о», and second prepositional case (also called locative) used after «в», «на», «по» which usually looks like Dative for masculine nouns.

    December 11, 2015

    https://www.duolingo.com/profile/madam_im_adam

    ah, so, лес is one of these words that has 2 prepositional cases then?

    December 11, 2015

    [deactivated user]

      Right.

      December 12, 2015

      https://www.duolingo.com/profile/madam_im_adam

      прекнрасный, спасибо ))

      December 12, 2015

      https://www.duolingo.com/profile/VioletteNoire

      I wrote "Мы гуляем по лéсу." which was accepted but I was wondering why the stress in 'лесу' changes to 'e' instead of 'y'...

      I am a native but I have no idea why it's so, it just feels right... Is there a rule for it?

      May 14, 2016

      [deactivated user]

        Sorry, I don't understand your question. You say stress changes from «е» to «у», but why should it be on «у»? Stress in all the singular forms of «лес» is on the first syllable of the word.

        • If this is a question about stress placement in «лес», then there are no real rules for stress in Russian words. There's Zaliznyak's article, but it's so technical and so long that it's easier to learn stress with each word.
        • If this is a question about shifting the stress to preposition, «по́ лесу», then I think stress can shift to the preposition only if it's normally on the first syllable of the word; and such stress shifts are generally optional (so both по ле́су and по́ лесу are correct).
        • If you're asking why we say «по лесу» and not «по ле́се», it's because «по» is used with Dative. (Edit: I've edited this sentence because it was incorrect before.)
        May 15, 2016

        https://www.duolingo.com/profile/VioletteNoire

        I don't know, it's just that me and my family would put the stress on 'y' if we'd say "в лесу", and pretty much any other Russian I know in my area...

        May 16, 2016

        [deactivated user]

          Oh, I see! Perhaps it's a regional difference, then.

          I've never heard «по лесу́» here in Belarus, but I guess it's different in different places.

          May 16, 2016

          https://www.duolingo.com/profile/VioletteNoire

          Oh I meant we do say "по ле́су" but when we use the preposition "в" we say "в лесу́" :)

          May 16, 2016

          https://www.duolingo.com/profile/ale7881

          Если уж быть более точным, то чаще говорим: Мы гуляем пОлесу, (одним словом), а не по лЕсу. С ударением на предлоге, а слово лесу произносим лису - пОлису. Мы гуляем по лесу будет звучать - Мы гылЯим пОлису(ы?). Безударное У часто звучит почти как Ы (слабое).

          January 16, 2018

          https://www.duolingo.com/profile/MetroWestJP

          Everything I've read says that when masculine nouns end in -у in the locative case, they are always stressed on the -у. Лесу, мосту, саду, etc. It's interesting to find out this isn't the same everywhere.

          November 28, 2018

          https://www.duolingo.com/profile/SvenEtienne

          Why is it лесу and not лесе

          April 21, 2017

          https://www.duolingo.com/profile/ale7881

          Думаем о лЕсе, но гуляем (ходим, бродим, собираем грибы) в лесУ. Думаем о парке и гуляем в парке! Есть такие "исключения" в русском. Называется по-научному Второй Предложный падеж (локативный) ...(местный).

          January 16, 2018

          https://www.duolingo.com/profile/AaronTupaz

          I wrote "Мы гуляем в лес." (Using accusative) Does this mean we are strolling to the forest?

          November 22, 2015

          [deactivated user]

            I doubt a native speaker would say «мы гуля́ем в лес». Гуля́ть has a shade of meaning 'to move without a clearly set direction'. Even though we usually have some route in mind when we go гуля́ть, the meaning of this word implies we can change the direction anytime because it's not really determined.

            That's why «в лес» doesn't work well with this verb: «в лес» suggests we have a fixed destination, and «гуля́ть» means we don't have it.

            November 23, 2015

            https://www.duolingo.com/profile/peachtree2

            So for the same reason we wouldn't want to say мы гуляем к лесу?

            February 1, 2016

            [deactivated user]

              «Мы гуля́ем к ле́су» sounds unnatural too, right.

              February 1, 2016

              https://www.duolingo.com/profile/raskolnikov88

              This reads to me as "we are walking to the forest". I'd have thought the distinction would be made clear, rather than being muddled like this.

              January 18, 2016

              [deactivated user]

                «В» has different meanings depending on the case of the noun:

                • в + prepositional case describes location and is translated 'in': «я живу́ в Ви́тебске» 'I live in Vitebsk', «я гуля́ю в па́рке» 'I walk in the park' (if the noun has a separate locative form, use it instead of the normal prepositional case form: «в лесу», not «в лесе»),
                • в + accusative case describes destination and is translated 'to, in, into': «я прие́хал в Лиссабо́н» 'I came to Lisbon', «я иду́ в теа́тр» 'I'm going to the theatre'.
                January 18, 2016

                https://www.duolingo.com/profile/raskolnikov88

                OK, got it, I think

                January 21, 2016

                https://www.duolingo.com/profile/MauriceReeves

                I wrote «В лесу мы гуляем» following another example in this lesson that had the prepositional phrase at the start of the sentence. Would it be correct to say it this way or should it have been «В лесу гуляем мы»?

                February 20, 2016

                [deactivated user]

                  In non-emphatic sentences, Russian places the known information in the beginning, and the new information in the end. So, here's the explanation of your sentences:

                  • «Мы гуляем в лесу» is a sentence answering the question "What do you do?". Мы is a known information (the listener expects the sentence about 'us'), «гуляем в лесу» is the new information (we tell what we're exactly doing).
                  • «В лесу мы гуляем» is a sentence answering the question "What do you do in the forest?". «В лесу» is a known piece information (the listener expects a sentence about the forest and about us), «мы» is also a known piece of information, and «гуляем» is the main piece of new information: we tell that we walk there (we don't work there, we don't pick up berries or mushroms, we just walk).
                  • «Мы в лесу гуляем» means roughly the same thing, but it's a more sentence about "us". I.e. if the previous was likely to be used to describe what people do in the forest (not neccessary what we do), this one is likely to describe what we do (not neccessary in the forest).
                  • «В лесу гуляем мы» is a sentence answering the question "Who does something in the forest?", "Who is in the forest?". «В лесу» is a known information (the listener expects a sentence about the forest), and the new information is that it's we there (it's not Ira who's walking there, it's us).
                  • «Гуляем в лесу мы» is a sentence answering the question "Who strolls in the forest?". I.e. the listener knows who goes to the forest to pick up mushrooms, but she doesn't know who goes there just for a walk, and we say: actually, we do. «Гуляем» is the main piece of the known information, «в лесу» is also a known information, and «мы» is the new information. This is more a sentence about walking than about a forest: 'we' walk in the forest, and someone else picks berries there.
                  • «В лесу гуляем мы» means roughly the same thing, but it's more a sentence about a forest and not about walking: we walk in the forest, and someone else walks in the steppe.
                  • «Гуля́ем мы в лесу́». Here, «гуля́ем» is the known information, and «в лесу́» is a new information. Such word order is often used to introduce a new situation as a background, because the new information here is «мы» and «в лесу́». Even in «гуля́ем» is not known by the listener (it's the beginning of the story, after all, listeners knows nothing!), placing it in the beginning marks it as something unimportant, already known. The important parts are placed near the end of the sentence: «мы» and «в лесу́». So, this sets a background for the following story that will be about us and that will happen in the forest (it doesn't matter much that we were walking before the story happened).

                  If you have no previous context, «Мы гуляем в лесу» is your best bet at translating "We are strolling in the forest", because this is the most common word order.

                  Hope that helps!

                  February 20, 2016

                  https://www.duolingo.com/profile/MauriceReeves

                  Thank you very much. That helps a bunch. I appreciate you going into so much depth. Thank you again!

                  February 20, 2016

                  https://www.duolingo.com/profile/JamSSteur

                  Stroll means walk in a leisurelyway and the closest Russian translation will be - ПРОГУЛИВАТЬСЯ rather than ГУЛЯТЬ So, the right translation shouls be Мы прогуливаемся в лесу!!!!

                  April 15, 2016

                  https://www.duolingo.com/profile/MichalaK_EU

                  Лесу doesn't look like a prepositional case. Why so?

                  September 17, 2018
                  Learn Russian in just 5 minutes a day. For free.