"Lui dice di no."

Translation:He says no.

January 10, 2013

This discussion is locked.


What is the syntax of "di" here?


It's like two point (idk how they are named in english " : " )... sooo He says: no


I'm a little confused with the use of "di" here. Can anyone offer some insight into the usage of "di"? Is used when quoting someone to indicate you're using their words, or something?


Me too. I'm sure it's just a way of speaking that can't be translated word for word into English, but it does seem odd.


Okay, really, can someone answer this? Why is "di" needed here!? I even had another exercise and the sentence was "Lui dice ciao." I kept trying to figure out how "di" was used here. I knew "He says of no" was obviously wrong, so I put "He answers with no." Then I find out the "di" is not even used. Someone please help us!


I asked my friend from Italy about this mysterious "di", and she explained, most of the time, if you leave out the "di" and just say "Lui dice no", you are directly quoting him as saying "no". But with the "di", it is an indirect quote of what he said. He maybe just said "no", or maybe he gave a long-winded answer and you sum it up as "no".

There is less overlap if the example is not him saying yes/no. If you want to say, "He says to go", you'd say "Lui dice di andare". It's not going to be a direct quote like that, because a sane person would probably not just say the infinitive "to go", full stop. So that sentence will always have "di". On the other hand, with "Lui dice ciao", it will always be a direct quote, so you won't ever use "di". If you wanted to say, "He says hi" as an indirect quote in Italian, you'd use a verb instead, and say "Lui ti saluta".

I hope this helps clear things up!


responses like this make me wish you could save comments on Duolingo


Perfect, even my Italian family couldn't answer this one. Props!


Yes, that helped. Grazie!


Thanks a lot! ❤️


Well "He answers with no" "He says with no" Why in English you would use "with" in one case and not in the other? No idea, but it is the same in Italian. It just how they quote other people's sayings.


I share everyone's confusion with this construction. Would it also be valid to simply say, "Lui dice no" ?


I am a Spanish speaker, so this makes more sense to me "El dice que no" "lui dice di no"


I am also a Spanish speaker. So, when we say "He says no" we say "El dice no" or also say "El dice que no". The traduction for the last one would be sometging like "He says that no" Sounds weird, yeah, but It actually makes sense for a Spanish speaker. So, with italian "Lui dice di no" the english traduction should be "He says that no"


Based on ritabuuk's explanation it sounds a little like this is the Italian equivalent of the English "He/she was like...". It's a way of establishing the reportive voice (I think that's what it's called) without the burden of having to quote verbatim.


Could it be also 'Lui dice che no.'?


I don't get it! Why does it have di in it when it isn't even in what it says in english?


Dumb duo, i never encountered this before. If it is in the lesson, then forgive me, but i dont remember


I translate this as "He says of no". Hence the di.

Learn Italian in just 5 minutes a day. For free.