"Masz chleb?"
Translation:Do you have bread?
61 CommentsThis discussion is locked.
What about "Do you have any bread?" This seems like a good translation, but it was counted wrong.
No. "Do you have any bread?" means "Masz jakiś chleb?". Between "Masz chleb?" and "Masz jakiś chleb?" is difference. Little, but yeah.
mary_beth I am a pole and I learned when exactly you have to use czy in a question. You should use it when you want to hear yes or no as an answer.
help me out on this one i wrote down this but now i am confused as hell, macie dzieci? = do you have children? but: masz chleb? = do you have bread? do they mean the same, or do you put/say masz if it is lifeless?
133
you (singular/plural) - ty (singular)/ wy (plural)
you have - masz (singular)/ macie (plural)
Do you have children? - Masz dzieci/ Macie dzieci
Do you have bread? - Masz chleb?/ Macie chleb
Should this be "czy masz chleb?" I don't understand when to use "czy" in a question.
- 308
Use "czy" when you like to use it. It's a useful word, if one has a problem of getting question-like-intonation clearly across. In other cases, the intonation (or a question mark) is enough - but versions with "czy" are still correct :)
Just from the audio you don’t get if it’s a question or a statement “ “you have bread”... so I think both should be accepted in this case...
Accusative. "Bread" is not animate, and for masculine non animate nouns their Accusative is the same as Nominative.
Having said that, there are quite a lot of nouns that are grammatically 'animate' for no reason, including most vegetables and fruits. But you will encounter it later, let's leave that aside now.
In English, "you" can be 2nd person singular, or 2nd person plural. Polish differentiates between them. So "masz" is for singular "you", and "macie" for plural "you".
At least the way of forming question sentences is easier than in Russian or Turkish.. =D
How is it easier than Russian? I mean, you can use ли, but at least in the Duolingo course, that wasn't too common... otherwise it was the same... Well, Polish has "czy".
Also, this is the same in Ukrainian. We use 'чи' ('сzy') 'do' in the beginning of the yes/no sentence. "Чи ти знаєш...?" ('Pronounced as: "Chy ty znayesh...?") for "Do you know...?" as in Polish: "Czy wiecz...?"
Absolutely not. Technically it ends with a p because of the final devoicing. This is not something a native speaker thinks of when pronouncing the word, it's just what happens in real speech.
Yes, although especially in a question, I wouldn't recommend it. I'd say either "Masz chleb?" (most neutral) or "Czy ty masz chleb?" (more emphasis on 'you').
"Jest mleko" is "There's milk". I don't think it has much to do with this sentence...
I typed in “maz chleb” (without the “s”) and it marked it as correct without comment.
Please post a screenshot the next time, we're trying to collect such screenshots.
Because "bread" is uncountable in English, it would have to be "a loaf of bread" (Polish: "bochenek chleba", sometimes "bochen chleba").
"Masz chleb" is more accusing or saying someone has bread. "Czy masz chleb?" should be the correct answer for "Do you have bread?" As "czy" would indicate a question instead of saying someone has bread. "Masz chleb?" Can work as a normal sentence asking if someone has bread, however it's slangier than should be taught I think.
Why whenever I put "a" in it is wrong? The other languages I learn always fixes me to put "a" in it. Does Polish have a word for "a" and "the"?
No, it doesn't, it's just that bread is uncountable in English so you can't really say "a bread". Other courses also wouldn't correct you to use "a bread".
With most other nouns, "a" would be required.
I wrote 'have you bread?' which is perfectly good English for 'do you have bread?' Duo does not understand that much English and rejected it. Reported.
I wrote 'Do you have bread' and it was rejected! But that was the answer!
How else are we supposed to teach them than by using them? Some basic nouns are taught by using pictures (and "chleb" is among them), but apart from that, I don't see other ways of introducing words.
- 1305
Why is "Have bread?" not accepted? Yes, it is less common, but it's a valid translation and used.
I imagined someone writing "Have bread?" on an English test and I think it is rather safer to reject it.