About possessive and reflexive pronouns in Polish.
Hi, I am starting this thread, because I’ve seen a lot of sentences in this course that use Polish possessive pronouns incorrectly. I decided to describe them more thoroughly here, maybe it would help somebody with their Polish. :)
In sentences, where object is described as belonging to the subject, in Polish one always uses possessive reflexive pronoun swój/swoja/swoje. Basic meaning of this pronoun in English is one’s own.
The reflexive possessive pronoun has identical forms for every person (I, thou, he, she, it, we, they-personal-and-masculine, they-not-personal-or-masc), although it does decline like adjective – changes its form in different cases, genders and numbers.
Because in English you can be both singular and plural, I’ll be making unnatural distinction in English examples and use archaic thou, thy for singular and dialectal y’all, y’all’s for plural.
So to say eg. Dost thou like thy car? in Polish, you would say:
Czy ty lubisz swój samochód?
Or just Lubisz swój samochód?, because question word and subject pronoun aren’t necessary.
And They are selling their house:
(Oni) sprzedają swój dom.
And I am visiting my mother:
(Ja) odwiedzam swoją matkę.
Anna is giving her (ie. Anna’s) book to Kasia.:
Anna daje swoją książkę Kasi.
My cat is biting its tail.:
Mój kot gryzie swój ogon.
In each of these sentences one uses swój, because the object (car, house, mother, book, tail) belongs to the subject (respectively: thou, they, I, Anna, cat).
It means that sentences such as:
- Dlaczego nie chcesz odwiedzać twojej babci? (Why do you not want to visit your grandmother?)
- Odwiedzacie waszego wujka? (Do you visit your uncle?)
- Wychowujesz twoje dzieci. (You raise your children.)
are incorrect, and should be changed to:
- Dlaczego nie chcesz odwiedzać swojej babci?,
- Odwiedzacie swojego wujka?,
- and Wychowujesz swoje dzieci? respectively.
I mean, they would be understood in their current form but they do sound weirdly and no sane sober Pole would say them in normal conversation.
On the other hand, when the object belongs to somebody else than the subject, we do use regular possessive pronouns: mój (my), twój (thy), jego (his), jej (her), nasz (our), wasz (y’all’s), ich (their). Third person pronouns jego, jej, ich are special and easy, because they do not decline (they are actually just genitive case of personal pronouns on, ona, oni/one).
So, eg. He is selling thy grandma would be:
(On) sprzedaje twoją babcię.
Y’all are buying his book:
(Wy) kupujecie jego książkę.
I am washing y’all’s cat:
(Ja) myję waszego kota.
In a somehow special case, when you speak to a group of people about an object that belongs to one of the group, in my opinion, you could use both forms:
Y’all, wash his car (where the car belongs to one of y’all):
Umyjcie twój/jego samochód.
But when saying twój, you would point at the owner, so it would be obvious about who you are talking.
And that also means that these sentences:
- To nie jest nasza flaga. (This is not our flag.)
- Mój brat odwiedza moją siostrę. (My brother is visiting my sister.)
- Nasze dzieci lubią ciasteczka. (Our children like cookies.)
are perfectly correct, because the object in the first two (flaga, flag; siostra, sister) belong to someone else than the subject (flag belongs to us and not to this, and sister belongs to me and not to my brother) and in the last two possessive pronoun is used to describe the subject itself (mój brat, my brother and nasze dzieci, our children).
Polish also have other reflexive pronouns, that are used as the object of the sentence, when the subject does something to themselves:
- się, siebie, oneself in accusative and genitive,
- sobie, in dative (to oneself) and in locative.
- sobą, in instrumental (using/with oneself)
They are used basically in the same manner, eg Thou dost not see thyself.:
(Ty) nie widzisz siebie.
I bought myself a Christmas gift.:
Kupiłem sobie prezent na Boże Narodzenie.
My cat is doing itself harm.:
Mój kot robi sobie krzywdę.
The hammer is pounding a nail with itself.:
Młotek wbija gwóźdź sobą.
And again, on ther hand, if the subject does something to somebody else, you use regular personal pronouns:
She gives a book to her (some another girl).:
Ona daje jej książkę.
I killed him.:
(Ja) zabiłem go.
Czyli dobrze zrobiłem, że się uczę tu polskiego ;) To "Odwiedzacie swojego wujka" brzmi mi strasznie nienaturalnie, pomimo że faktycznie jest poprawne. Czyli nie jestem sane :( Ale z linku wynika, że nie tylko ja. http://portalwiedzy.onet.pl/140789,,,,moj_swoj,haslo.html
From those three sentences odwiedzacie waszego wujka actually sounds somehow OK to me, the other two are very unnatural IMO. Anyway, I’d still say swojego wujka, and not waszego, and I didn’t want to complicate things in the post by adding that in some contexts, and especially in plural, using the regular non-reflexive possessives might sound not-that-bad.
Anyway, your link makes a very good point about using regular pronouns for emphasis (like in Wzięłam moje klucze, nie twoje, I took my keys, not yours). When writing the post I wasn’t thinking about that.
Using possessive reflexive pronouns where one should use regular possessive pronouns is a grammatical calque from English and is a quite popular language mistake. You are going to face it many times but it's not right. Just as swapping it's with its, and than with then (though these ones are only matter writing and can't be heard in speech).