"Porozmawiałeś z nią?"

Translation: Have you talked with her?

[Mr.aljabry]

Can I translate it into spoke instead of talked?

[Jellei]

I think "Have you spoken with her?" could work, but "talk" somehow seems better.

[JerryMcCarthy99]

Confirmed (a bit late, I know).

[Maksym626803]

As I know, there is no reason to use Present Perfect here. If the time of the completed action is not important, it is expressed with Past Simple: "Did you talk to her?"

[BenYoung84]

But it is not clear from the Polish sentence whether the time of the completed action is important or not.

[Jellei]

Which works. But Present Perfect also seems perfectly fine. In fact, as "porozmawiałaś" somehow sounds as if I knew that my interlocutor was supposed to talk with her, I feel that Present Perfect really suits this sentence well.

[Walkinthedog]

I also like have you spoken with her

[Jellei]

Works.

[aniahime]

In the audio, I don't hear the "po" - only the "rozmawiales" .....

[Alfonso_C_]

It has been fixed, it seems ;)

[Yulia304814]

It doesn't accept "has talked" but propose "had talked". Why?

[Jellei]

You have 2nd person here, in English "has talked" only works for 3rd person singular.

[ijbrito]

why nia?

[JerryMcCarthy99]

Because, in this case, "z(e)" takes instrumental ( https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Polish/Prepositions_as_hints_to_declensions )
and instrumental of "ona" is "nią" ( https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/ona#Declension_2 and see section 6.3.1 ).

[Mrs.Mop]

Were you talking to her ?

[JerryMcCarthy99]

Same answer as your other comment.....

[Mrs.Mop]

Were you speaking with her ... Didn't work

[alik1989]

The Polish verb is perfective, so it can't be past continuous in English.