"Where is a clock?"

Translation:Gdzie jest zegar?

May 28, 2016

This discussion is locked.


So a noun does not take the instrumental case when the sentence begins with a question-word?


"Zegar" is the subject. so it is in Nominative. More information here: https://www.duolingo.com/comment/12789901


why could I not use 'to' but was told to use 'ten'. 'gdzie to zegar' was wong, 'gdzie ten zegar' was right


Well, "Gdzie to zegar" makes no sense, because "to" is neuter and "zegar" is masculine. "to" also cannot be a dummy pronoun here (as in "To jest zegar" = "This/That/It is a clock"), because it also doesn't suit the sentence at all.

If you were thinking about "to" as in "Kot to zwierzÄ™", 'to' doesn't exactly mean 'is', it is more like a '=' sign. That's why you absolutely can't use it here.

"ten" was suggested because it's the closest accepted answer. As it means "this", it's an interpretation of "the" (Where is the clock, Where is this clock).

In the questions about 'where is something' you can omit "jest" (Gdzie [jest/] [ten/] zegar?), but it may be considered impolite, so I do not recommend it.


Thank you, that explains a lot.

Learn Polish in just 5 minutes a day. For free.