"I am listening to them."
Wrong case. Słuchać mostly takes Genitive*, and Genitive both from "oni" and "one" is "ich". But if you were to say, for example, "I like them", that would take Accusative and be "Lubię je" (or "Lubię ich" for masculine personal). Also note that if you were to use any preposition before any of them, then they would change into 'nich' or 'nie', respectively.
*Apart from the situations when you're directly addressing someone: "I'm listening to you", then it takes Accusative. But obviously that's not the situation in this sentence.