"הילד לומד אנגלית באופן עצמאי."
Translation:The boy is learning English independently.
24 CommentsThis discussion is locked.
WHAT ABOUT : THE CHILD IS LEARNING ENGLISH BY HIMSELF.... OR THE CHILD IS STUDYING ENGLISH INDEPENDENTLY???
Could this be translated as "The boy is learning English on his own", as well? Or is "on one's own" a different expression in Hebrew?
Could someone please explain what באופן means as I see it is part of multiple phrases but I just don't see the connection.
It means in a manner of __ or in a __ way as in: in a strange way- באופן מוזר
1565
According to the Tips and Notes for this lesson, 'Many adverbs that end in "-ly" in English are paraphrased in Hebrew by using the word אופן ("way", "manner"):
עצמאי - independent באופן עצמאי - independently (literally "in an independent way")'
The word עצם means "bone" or the "stuff" you're made of. It is the "substance" of something. It is the "self." אופן means manner/method/way of doing something, but I happen to like "cycle" and the word is even adapted to describe riding a biCYCLE:
רכב על אופניים
Every revolution of the wheels is a cycle and many revolutions accomplish getting from point A to point B. I feel our given exercise parallels the English like this:
The boy studies English in a self-based cycle.
I hope my buddy Danny doesn't get upset (I know, friend, we can't translate stuff this way.)
:D
Thanks Ingeborg. I'm glad you're here. Somewhere in these exercises was something about growing loads of carrots but also vegetables באופן כללי. I did find "cyclist" as a potential meaning for אופן (pronounced the same way) in one of the dictionaries and ofahn is at least a close cousin word meaning "wheel," as you pointed out. I deduced that both nouns employ the method of "cycling" and, therefore, the act of turning/rotating/making revolutions repeatedly was likely the basis for choosing the word אופן to portray the method/manner/way/custom in question... It repeats, comes back around, over and over again. That's how an ofehn eventually became an ofehn... Repetition. Using ofehn as "cycle" seemed to fit ok with regard to the "crop cycling" in the agriculture exercise. Now, I didn't dare translate it this way (for fear of the beloved trolls burning down a heart), but I did parallel באופן כללי as "in a customary cycle," momentarily, before actually inputting "in general."
Think I've completely lost it yet?
:D
Not sure what you mean by accent (probably the stress accent, which is on the [i]), but you may listen to the word at Forvo: עַצְמָאִי
That could mean a number of things, and independent learning (without the help of others) is only one of them. For instance, he may be in a class of 30 students who spend a lot of time together, but at this moment he's by himself (alone in his room) doing his homework.
- 453
Could it also be הילד לומד באופן עצמאי אנגלית. i.e. can the adverb come right after the verb, or does it mirror English in that it comes after the object (in this case, "English")
Yes, you can vary the normal word order to change the rhythm of the sentence, for example if you want to contrast languages, the last word in a sentence giving the new information: בַּכִּתָּה הוּא לָמַד גֶּרְמָנִיתְ אַך לְאַחַר מִּכֵּן לָמַד בְּאֹ֫פֶן עַצְמָאִי אַנְגְּכִית in class he learnt German, but after that he learnt English independently.
The boy is learning English independtly...what you demand but after 10 times of repeating i am not credited
- 899
You have just felt independently with a missing syllable. Perhaps that's what you did before. I believe I've seen DL let people by with a typo when there is just one letter wrong, but with two letters missing, they mark it wrong.