"Kik zenélnek a tenger mellett?"

Translation:Who is playing music by the sea?

July 3, 2016



But why "ïs"? Why not "are". I do not understand.

July 3, 2016


There's a tendency for English speakers to ask in the singular even if they expect the answer in the plural.

July 3, 2016


But "are" is not wrong, if it is understood that the answer is plural.

August 13, 2016


Hmm, most sources consider it wrong and my own native-speaker intuition is that it is very, very odd sounding.

The only exception is when using the verb to be as a copula, linking "who" with a plural noun or pronoun.

Who are they?
Who are those people?
Who are your friends?

In those cases, you could argue that the plural noun or pronoun is syntactically the subject and "who" is only at the beginning because of wh-fronting.

Who is eating? (Not "Who are eating?")
Who is in the room? (Not "Who are in the room?")
Who sleeps together? (Not "Who sleep together?")

"They hate chocolate"
"Who hates chocolate?" (Not "Who hate chocolate?")

It feels a bit awkward whenever you have "each other" straight after it though.

Who hates each other ... doesn't feel quite right.

The relative pronoun "who" can go with plural verbs:

All the people who are coming to the party ...

Possibly, "Who are playing music?" is grammatical in some dialects of English, but I don't think I've ever heard a native speaker say this.

September 17, 2016


Both are grammatical andcan be used, but the more informal the register the less likely that "are" will be used. http://ell.stackexchange.com/questions/52038/is-who-singular-or-plural

September 24, 2016


Why is "beside the sea" wrong? It means the same as "next to" in English.

August 16, 2016


Sounds a bit uncommon, but it is not wrong.

September 26, 2016


To me, a Brit, by the sea is most common, followed by beside and next to in that order. There's an old song, "I do like to be beside the seaside, I do like to be beside the sea".

September 26, 2016


I wrote exactly what the 'correct' answer said and it still said its wrong.....

January 12, 2017


If it keeps doing this, you might file for a bug report.

January 12, 2017


I've had that happen occasionally as well.

July 29, 2017
Learn Hungarian in just 5 minutes a day. For free.