1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: German
  4. >
  5. "Ich mag Hunde, aber meine Sc…

"Ich mag Hunde, aber meine Schwester mag Katzen."

Translation:I like dogs, but my sister likes cats.

February 3, 2014



So presumably 'aber' is NOT a subordinating conjunction? Otherwise the sentence would end "...aber meine Schwester Katzen mag."?


That's right. aber is a coordinating conjunction. Here it's used to combine two main clauses.

It could also be used to combine two subordinate clauses:

„Er weiß, dass ich Hunde [mag], aber meine Schwester Katzen mag.“


Verb does not change its position in some relative cluses (clauses that begin with aber, und, denn...).


Lol that was for Alex


Could someone explain please, why 'Schwester mag' and not 'Schwester magt'?


Interesting! I had the same question. Danke für die Hilfe!


What's the role of the coma here? Is it mandatory, only recommanded or optional?


IMO it's mandatory here. While the comma before some coordinating conjunctions is omitted…

„Ich gehe zuerst und du folgst mir.“ – „I go first and you follow me.“

…when the conjunction implies a contrast or difference such as aber, doch, jedoch or sondern, there has to be a comma, even for coordinating conjunctions:

„Ich gehe, aber du bleibst here.“ – „I go but you stay here.“


I think you'll find that this is the German section lol


How can it say i pronounced well if it cuts before i finish speaking?


whats the difference of "Doch" and "Aber"?


'Doch' is used to show agreement. 'Aber' means but, or however.


Probably i should have asked sooner, but Kater vs. Katzen.,.what's the diff?


die Katze (plural die Katzen) is grammatically feminine word for the biological family of animals and it can both mean a female and a male cat.

der Kater (plural die Kater) is grammatically masculine and means specifically a male cat.

If you explicitly want to talk about a female cat, there is the grammatically feminine word die Kätzin (pl. die Kätzinnen), but IMHO it's not used that often. AFAIK the usage of adjectives is more common here:
„eine weibliche Katze“ – “a female cat”

Learn German in just 5 minutes a day. For free.
Get started