"Szukam małej torby."

Translation:I am looking for a small bag.

July 22, 2016

This discussion is locked.


Can someone explain why? I don't get the grammarrules....


Well, you have to know what case is needed with a given verb, or a preposition. "szukać" needs Genitive, so "mała torba" is in Genitive.

I don't think there's a better way to learn this than just to learn by heart... You will make mistakes, of course, but at some time you will just know.


But it's małej torby?


I think Jellei meant that what in the nominative would be "mała torba" needs to go into the genitive.

i.e. "...so "mała torba" goes into the Genitive" -- małej torby


Yes. After all, the English is "to look <for something>" which would put the sought for item into the Dative, if English still had a Dative case :-) .


It is "małej torby" indeed. Or "(małej) torebki", as we usually accept diminutives when it's "small something". And frankly, it seems to me that "torebka" is more common than "torba" for a woman's handbag.


I just try to Learn by heart the verbs that force a certain form


Is torba an irregular? I would think that it's genitive would be "torbi", just like other feminine nouns ended in "a"


Well, there are rules about whether a genitive takes -i or -y.

The most important rule is that nouns ending in -ga or -ka have their genitives in -gi or -ki. Many of the fem. nouns encountered in this course end in -ka, so you get to see a lot of -ki genitives.

This goes some way to explain why "torba" -> "torby" but "torebka" -> "torebki" as mentioned in Jellei's response just above this conversation.



Yes, I wish there were a small list of words in all their forms for the words in the exercises.


I think i get it. Torba is feminine. So one would say mała torba. But with the verb szukam małej (jej) torby. Polish is bloody weird. The grammar is kicking my arse.


Why not "seeking"?


Oversight, added now.


Although not commonly used in conversational English :-)


I think it would help learning a lot if when you click on a word it shows not only the meaning but also gender, number and case (and ideally even the root word). I made zero headway with the grammar despite reaching this point which expects quite a lot of grammatical knowledge. Eventually went and bought a book instead


I'm looking for a small handbag


Is that not a "torebka"?


If I remember correctly torebka is more likely to be a purse, or maybe a clutch.


more likely to be a purse.

Which is exactly the word used in (parts of) the USA for the Br. Eng. term "handbag".


I'd use "torebka" for most bags, including women's handbags, unless it's really quite a large one. Personally I would choose to teach it rather than "torba", although it's not like "torba" is an uncommon word.

Added "handbag". And "purse".

Learn Polish in just 5 minutes a day. For free.