"Péter is in the hospital."

Translation:Péter kórházban van.

July 26, 2016

This discussion is locked.


"Péter a kórházban van"? Doesn't omitting "a" make it mean something more general, like "Peter is hospitalized" or "Peter is in a hospital"?


I share your opinion. I reported it.


I posted this in the other thread too, but I think it's worth noting that I think it's like the British Peter is in hospital, and it's American English (specifically) that throws in this definite article unnecessarily.


That is very interesting, thanks!
It also reminds me of playing the violin.


It's awkward, because American English is really inconsistent: in school, in college, in jail/court/prison, at lunch, at work, at sea, in flight, in office (political) are OK everywhere, but not at university, in hospital (those are British only) and definitely not at doctor, at job, at store, at ocean (all require an article, even in England, I think)


Interesting. I don't think "at university" is wrong in American English though (it's just usually "at college" instead). It'd be the difference between physically at the site without necessarily being a student ("the") vs. attending university as a student (no "the").


I guess it's not wrong, but it's pretty rare (though maybe it's used in Canada), so that I don't have a reading on whether it sounds good or not, except that it sounds British.


In English, Péter is in the hospital usually means that he's in a generic hospital. I'm assuming that it is marked wrong because the same construct in Hungarian would mean that he is in a specific hospital.

Ones like this are a bit tricky, and depend on context. But (assuming I'm right with the above) it's probably correct for Duolingo to mark off. If you meant a specific hospital, you'd probably name it...


It's hard to tell with Duolingo; sometimes you need to translate something very literally, even if it's a little awkward or has a slightly different meaning in the other language, and other times you're marked wrong for being too literal. (For example, many languages use the definite "the [noun]" to mean the equivalent of English's indefinite "[nouns]" but Duolingo rarely accepts such a translation.) I think both "a kórházban" and "kórházban" should be accepted here.


You are right, I agree.


"Péter a kórházban van" is accepted now. (2017.05.26.)


Péter kórházban van = he is sick, he has a surgery, etc., so he is a patient. Péter a kórházban van = he is in the building, and you know in which hospital. But he can be also there, because he is a patient, or because he works there.


Why is the answer -ban in a lesson over -nal

  1. I am seeing this thread in a lesson on -ban/-ben.
  2. For this particular sentence, -ban is correct regardless of which lesson it appears in.


If Peter is in THE hospital, (rather than Peter is in hospital), how is use of the direct article here (Peter az korhazban van) incorrect?


Péter a kórházban van is accepted.

a/az mistake

Learn Hungarian in just 5 minutes a day. For free.