- Forum >
- Topic: Polish >
- "Mój tata kupuje mi rower."
23 Comments
"Tata" and "mężczyzna" are clearly masculine because of their meaning, even if they sound feminine and have feminine declension.
Some other words that work like that but are a bit less logical are for example "turysta" (a tourist) and "artysta" (an artist). Their feminine versions are "turystka" and "artystka". There are not many such exceptions, don't worry.
Ok thanks - it is confusing when words are masculine in meaning - but in function are feminine or decline like feminine words. :)
Would "dla mnie" be an acceptable alternative to the simple "mi"?
For some time we rejected it because it's a different construction, then we started accepting such answers.
However, "Mój tata kupuje rower dla mnie" sounds kinda strange to me. This repetition of "mój"/"mnie". If anything, I'd say "Tata kupuje rower dla mnie"...
Also, emphasizing "dla mnie" could feel like "for me, not for you!"
Sounds strange, but that's how people speak in Białystok. https://pl.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gwara_białostocka
Wiktionary says that "tata" is informal, so I guess it doesn't really match "(my) father".
840
Hi Jerry, in another exercise tata was used as father, there's an inconsistency, hence my question. Thank you for replying, I wish we had an open forum, or chat room to exchange ideas ot tips. Thanx again
In which case, I guess it was just an oversight, and might be corrected at some point.
As for general fora, on the website (I can't speak for the App) there is a link on the main front page which takes you to https://forum.duolingo.com/ where there are multiple discussions that you can join, or start your own.
Why is "My dad's buying me a bicycle" not accepted? Normally these contractions are accepted.
Probably just an oversight; if you get it again, I'd suggest you could report it.
From what I see in a dictionary, the definition seems to be rather wider than just "bicycle".
By the way, your comment is literally the only time I have encountered "cycle" used that way...
Please could you accept bike as well as bicycle because that is certainly the word used universally in the uk rather than bicycle. Ok, I know bike could mean motorbike as well in English, but bicycle sounds so stilted nowadays. I have reported it as well
I've forgotten now. Maybe I made another silly mistake I didn't notice. Sorry
So, we have "mi" (dative of ja) because it works like and indirect object here, right? Also, I was checking the wikitionary and I saw that "mnie" could also be the dative of "ja". Is this correct? If so, could it be used in this sentence?
The other accepted version is "dla mnie" ("for me"); there's a bit of a discussion on this up the page from three years ago.
Incidentally, "mnie" here is the Genitive form of "ja" (required after "dla"), rather than the Dative.
Dative "mnie" is relatively rare, it's the emphasized version. I would definitely not use it here.
