1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: Hungarian
  4. >
  5. "Hova nézünk fel?"

"Hova nézünk fel?"

Translation:Where are we looking up?

August 16, 2016



The problem is 'where are we looking up to' isn't very natural English. If you are already looking up, why you ask which direction to look in? What context would the Hungarian sentence be used in?


Google finds turns up exactly one instance of this sentence being used anywhere on the Internet, and it is in this very thread on Duolingo. Please, course developers, don't invent garbage sentences that nobody would ever say or write and expect us to learn from them. They just waste our time trying to translate improbable Hungarian into improbable English.


If you were standing around, and someone say "look up" - you might reply "where do we look up to?"


No we wouldn't. This English sentence is nonsense.


------ well, we'd say, "where to ? " . . .

Big 8 jul 18


------- or even, "where at ? " . . .

Big 16 aug 20


Perhaps if you knew that people were looking at a particular planet or star but you didn't know exactly where to look, you might ask "Where are we looking?" but I can't imagine an English speaker adding "up" at the end of the question. "What are we looking up at?" is a meaningful English sentence, but it doesn't work with "Where" in place of "What".


Yes, realistically "Where are we looking?" is the equivalent English sentence, and if I were doing a professional translation that's how I would translate it, but Hungarian naturally includes more information in such sentences, and in an educational context it's important we learn that, even if representing our understanding in English is awkward.


Should this be "Where are we looking up at?" (rather than "to")


Hova implies a direction rather than a target, which I think is well translated with 'to'. "Where are we looking up at?" doesn't make a lot of sense to me, but it seems like it's asking for an object to be looked at. I would translate that with "Mire nezünk fel?", then.


It doesn't matter if "hova" means "to where" if there is no such usage in English. Perhaps "What are we looking up at?" "What are we looking at up there"? "Why are we looking up"?


'Where do we look up' would make much more sense.

Learn Hungarian in just 5 minutes a day. For free.