"A színésznő átül abba az autóba."
Translation:The actress moves over to sit in that car.
26 CommentsThis discussion is locked.
ül = sits
átül = moves over to sit somewhere else
ültet = make someone sit somewhere. Or: to plant
átültet: makes someone move and sit somewhere else. Or: transplant (replant a plant from one pot to another. / transplant an organ)
átültetés = transplantation
szíváltültetés = heart transplanation
A teacher can say when students don't behave: Maradjatok csendben vagy szétültetlek! Be quiet or I make you sit somewhere away from each other.
Is more of that kind of thing coming up in the tree (section 4?) That looks pretty interesting.
I had to super-duper report this particular example because the Word Bank has a grammatical error - "The actress sit in that car" was accepted.
Why not “to sit into that car” as suggested by the hint? To my Californian ear, that would do no damage to the English.
What is this supposed to mean? "to sit over into something" I understand neither the Hungarian nor the English sentence.
"Át-" usually indicates a movement between two similar positions. Here, from sitting in one car to sitting in another car.
English: "The actress moves over and sits in that car." "moves over to sit in that car"
I changed the solution from The actress sits over into that car.
to "The actress moves over to sit in that car"
The translations seriously have to get more relaxed. I'm sick of spending nearly 20 minutes on a small section
There are quite a few instances in the revision exercise of this module where perfectly sensible translations are not "the correct solution" or there is a problem with using British as opposed to American English. I am reporting them, in the hope that there will be some improvement.
"Segítünk! Ne hagyja el a gépjárművét! Ha elfogy az üzemanyaga, üljön át másik gépjárműbe!"
(We help! Do not leave your vehicle! If you run out of fuel, sit in another vehicle!)
Said the sms sent by the Ministry of Interior on March 15, 2013, when a lot of people got stuck in a huge show storm. It became a meme.
just to show an example for átül
I totally agree, i am english and would never say sits over- not, definitely not English. Very bad grammar
1133
All hail jzsuzsi! This sentence and its English translation offer some necessary insight into the differences between English and Hungarian. In this case, we get to see how Hungarian can use a single word (átül) to express what English does in two words (move over and sit). If we are going to learn Hungarian, we need this kind of translation. Literal, word-for-word translations will only yield confusion, and the comments here are ample proof of that. jzsuzsi dispels the confusion and gives us the real thing here. Let's hope there's more to come.
This too could utilize the act of moving over to ...x... so, for non-native English-speaking folk, "The actress moves into that car (some small distance away) and sits. (we would not repeat ...sits into that car.)
- 681
I thought it meant "the actress sits over in that car", as in "she is sitting in the car over there" but that might just be the southern grammer coming out in me - Im not actually sure if that's acceptable English outside the SE USA.
The word bank didn't give the option of "into" but rather "in to" and I got told I have an extra space
- it should be 'sits' not 'sit' because 'the actress' indicates that it's singular
- alos; there's another mistake in this sentence because there's no option of 'into'; only 'in' and 'to'; while duo keeps correcting you that you should use 'into'
I rather thought that this would be an interesting place to visit. I can't make much sense of the English translation either. Átül = sits across or, as jzsuzsi says, moves over to sit somewhere else. But the actress is getting into the car, she isn't in it already and thus we have ba rather than ban. How, from a position outside of a car, can you sit across into a new sitting position? Was she sitting on a chair outside the car and was it from that sitting position that she moved? I picture an extremely famous actress on a sedan chair being decanted into a limousine.
I want to develop that if I can. A híres színésznő ebből az autóból átúl abba az autóba. Does that work?
That works. (not átúl, but átül)
A híres színésznő ebből az autóból átül abba az autóba.
- 803
English translation is clumsy. "The actress moves across to that car" - sitting is implied as one cannot do much other, so should this not be accepted?
I think i am getting this finally. So maybe i am just posting for others. The preverbs (like at-) add some movement to the verb in many cases that is not inherent to the verb on its own. For instance - as jzsuzsi says here - atul means to move over and sit, not just sit over there.