Translation:Was your baby born?
Despair thy charm, Duo! And let the angel whom thou still hast served tell thee, Macduff was from his mother's womb untimely ripp'd.
No, it wasnt born. It was hatched out of a cabbage. Geez. I would never say it this way. Did you give birth as yet?, maybe. did you have the baby? Perhaps. Was the baby born indicates there is doubt it ever was. Which is just sad.
Yes, miscarriages are sad, but they do happen. Stop trying to impose your English on Japanese and let Japanese teach you. What's common for them to say doesn't match English.
Perhaps I could have chosen my words better. This was merely a comment on the chosen translation for those learning English to be careful of using an English sentence like this, as it begs snarky ribbing or cheeky replies, (as has been seen by a few other posters here besides me) which would likely cause quite a bit of confusion with the English learner as to why.
Did you have your baby? Was marked wrong. Should that be an acceptable answer?
It might be casual, but I would use it just like "Did you give birth?" If you know someone is pregnant, you haven't spoken with them for a while, and then in an email or on the telephone you could ask. (Because if you were talking face to face, it would be easy to tell if she was still pregnant or not).
I have been known thanks to you.
I think we use same situation this sentence "赤ちゃんは生まれましたか？ ".
And we ask this sentence when we meet to a man who has pregnant wife, too.
"I know now, thanks to you.
I think we would use this sentence in the same situation: "赤ちゃんは生まれましたか？"
And we would ask this question when we meet a man whose wife is pregnant, too."
I do think that's an acceptable translation, but I would recommend "Was your baby born?" because the verb 生まれる specifically means "was born" in English. Even if you get that idea across with your translation, it's good to connect the verb with its meaning during practice so that it's not forgotten in other contexts.
"Did you have a baby" - marked wrong. Most of the time the "wrong" answers are because of the narrow allowable translations. In this case - as many point out - the translation is comically odd.
Because in this case the subject is "baby", so you're asking if the baby was born
I agree the translation is odd but, in my opinion, your answer is understandably incorrect. The original translation implies you were already aware of the other's pregnancy, and are simply curious as to whether or not they've given birth. Your question vaguely asks "did you have a baby?" They could respond yes whether or not they were even pregnant recently, because even though their child is now a 15 year old teen battling puberty, that 15 year old was once a baby that the person in question definitely once had. So, regardless of the odd translation, your question is far from synonymous. It would be more accurate to ask "have you given birth yet?" Which I'll admit is still somewhat strange to ask, bc in most cases, anyone remotely close to giving birth is evident upon first glance. To ask is nearly an insult, whether or not they've given birth yet.
No, the original Japanese implies you were already aware of the other's pregnancy, and are simply curious as to whether or not they've given birth. The original translation implies you were already aware of the other's baby, and are simply curious as to particular manner in which it came into existence.
The distance between those two is greater than the distance between either and Filvorn's answer.
How would you say ‘has your baby been born’? Is it a different grammatical structure? And how would Japanese people tend to say this?
Some Japanese would simply say 赤ちゃんは生まれましたか? Others might say 赤ちゃんは生まれてきた? The ~tekita form of a verb is often used to mean "have (just/recently) done something" in modern Japanese. Other examples,
私は帰ってきた! I have returned!
私はソファを買ってきた I have bought a sofa.
And when he grows up a bit, he can recruit a dog, a monkey and a pheasant to help him kick the demons out of 鬼ヶ島。
It is a sentence that should never be asked this way in english as it implies that it is either dead or born and would stir even a strong hearted parent or parent-to-be! This question needs "yet" to be included for the speaker to avoid any ambiguous confusion.
赤ちゃん（あかちゃん） is just the Japanese word for baby. 赤 is a noun meaning "red" (and 赤い is its adjective form). Some theorize about the etymology of 赤ちゃん that the term is based on the redness of a baby's cheeks.
I heard it came from the redness of the baby's rear end after the doctor spanks it.
The verb is in past tense: '生まれました'. That is why you need to use 'was' instead of 'is'.
Japanese past tense does not always correspond to the English past tense. In this case, "Has the baby been born?" could be an appropriate translation.
Someone explain this... Is that question right? (i am a spanish speaker) how could it be posible? A question that have not " what, how, who, when , at the beginning.
They do tend to contain is/are/do/was/were/did/will, though. That's what this question is asking: was?
They're typically yes or no because you can typically either be or not be. But do I like chocolate? Sometimes.
There are plenty of other words like this. "Can", "may", and "should" for instance.
You can certainly ask a question in English without one of these words in it, like "smell that?" But that's just an abbreviation of "do you smell that?"
I can't tell you how lenient spoken Japanese gets, though.
I just realized
"Is that question right?"
has not what, how, who, when, at the beginning
how could it be possible?
"Has our baby been born yet?" (assuming he's asking a nurse or doctor)
私のあかちゃんはうまれましたか？ Although, in japanese u could easily omit the "my" part of the question, making it exactly the same as the original duolingo question, as long as the doctor already knows that you are the father, whom is presumably eagerly awaiting the baby's arrival in the waiting room like a total P**Y!
I am imagining that a woman and her husband are at the hospital and a relative or friend is asking this question. But still an odd question. Like the hope that it wasnt born or maybe a better question "is she still in labor?" You hope and pray the baby is born. So I agree I try to imagine a situation this question would be asked but still inappropiate. Like maybe how was the baby concieved Lol! Was it by artifical insemination? Haha. Genetically engineered? Test tube baby? Did you adopt? But idk maybe in Japan this question is common. There are many things one would think are rude in another country.