"あれはかのじょのものです。"

Translation: That is hers.

[jiofox]

"that is her stuff" should also work

[insincere]

Yeah I too was marked wrong for this

[cmorwin]

Still wrong August 2018.

Especially frustrating after being taught 私の物 is "my stuff" but 彼女の物 is not "her stuff", which makes the most sense.

「Consistency」をください！

[cmorwin]

Still wrong Jan 2019...

[AsiaticTraveler]

I agree

[Falcon198016]

あれは彼女のものです

[mkeays]

あれは彼女の物です

[IsolaCiao]

I'd say that "mono" in kana is the standard (see definition 2).

[kbreddit]

Could you also say 'That thing is hers.'?

[Vynaut]

No that would be あのもの, grammatically this sentence is saying 'That is her thing'.

[Emer_Learns]

But "that is her thing" is not accepted (as of 5th Nov 2017), even tho it's a close translation and a legit English sentence! I reported it.

[kittycat2223]

Most likely.

[Sintanity]

I almost want to argue that "That is her stuff" is more right than "that's hers" because "mono" translates to stuff.. maybe I'm not understanding some nuance?

[mattj36]

Could you also write that belongs to her?

[ahANpg]

If that is the case, then もの will be lost in translation

[karsivallinen]

Shouldn't "Those are hers" be correct as well?

[atreyu.0]

Was wondering the same thing...

[FrederickEason]

Yes. Report it.

[austin_s44]

Couldn't you just say あれは彼女のです ? What's the significance of adding 物 ? Is this just a more formal way of saying it?

[BastTee]

Yes that's it, you can skip もの in conversation with your friends. :)

[ahANpg]

I would prefer "Those are her belongings"

[Daxnassrac]

Why does "this is my thing" work for これはわたしのものです。and "that is her thing" not work for あれはかのじょのものです?

[LXwong]

Those are the girl's things.

[Emer_Learns]

No, the pronoun is used here. It says "her" not "the girl". It could refer to a female baby, female old woman, maybe even a female robot, female cat, etc, not necessarily a/the girl.

[Leo456036]

Could this be "That is my girlfriend's" too?

[Ka_HU]

I think it could be (should be). Also:

Those are my girlfriend's

Those are my girlfriend's things

[J_Hammy]

Heard this as おれはかのじょでず <3

[CaueJ.]

Marked wrong for using "That is her things". Is it really wrong?

[IsolaCiao]

“That” is singular and “things” is plural so you wouldn’t be able to use them together like that.