1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: German
  4. >
  5. "Dieser Wein kommt aus Spanie…

"Dieser Wein kommt aus Spanien."

Translation:This wine is from Spain.

March 6, 2013



what's wrong with "this wine comes from Spain"


Nothing. Report it.


I wrote ˝This wine comes from Spain˝ and it was correct -.-


Why is it "dieser" Wein?

  • 1211

We want "this" or "these", which is a "dies-" stem. "Wein" is a masculine noun and it's the subject, so you use masculine nominative and it becomes "dieser Wein".


'This wine comes from Spain' is surely correct?


Yep, that is also a correct translation!


Why Dieser and not Diese


Wein ist singularisch und Maskulinum, nicht pluralisch.


from: when is auf or aus?


'auf' never means from, but rather on or upon (auf dem Tisch=on the table)


Can someone explain to me Dies and Das?


LMGTFY: See this explanation by sakasiru.


Thanks a lot for the explanation. Makes sense!


Is there anything wrong with "This is wine from Spain"?


It's just a different sentence. The two sentences convey the same information, but the construction is different. "Dieser Wein kommt aus Spanien" breaks down into: '[this wine] is/comes from Spain'. Your breakdown of: '[this] is [wine from Spain]' would be "Das/dies ist Wein aus Spanien." 'This wine' specifies the subject as wine, whereas 'this' could be 'whatever is in this box, behind the curtain,' etc.


When would i use Dies, Dieses, Das?


Dieses is used when the next word is a neuter noun. For example, "Dieses Auto ist rot." Das is used for neuter nouns as well, but means 'the' when it is the article for the noun. However, it can also mean 'that' or 'this' when at the beginning of a sentence. I do not see 'Dies' used very often, so I cannot say much about it quite yet.


'kommt' = 'is' ?


The verb 'kommen' = 'to come'. There is some ambiguity here, because the German sentence can be translated as : 'This wine comes from Spain' or 'This wine is from Spain'. The reverse is also true that I can say 'Dieser Wein ist aus Spanien' or 'Dieser Wein kommt aus Spanien' to convey the same meaning.


Why is the translation 'is'not 'comes ', surely 'is'is quite clearly 'ist'.Am confused by this.


The translation is not word-for-word. If you chose to translate each word individually, "Dieser Wein kommt aus Spanien" becomes "This wine comes out of Spain," or "This wine comes from Spain." Note how aus can be translated two ways: as "from" or as "out of".

But of course one could also understand what the German sentence means, and then express that same idea in English, so that "Dieser Wein kommt aus Spanien" is "This wine is from Spain."

(Note how in the first paragraph I use "becomes" and in the second "is". Two words, similar usage, same end effect.)


So I'm kinda confused with the word "Diese" and "dieser" I am still wrapping my mind around it and its difficult to know when I'm supposed to use Diese and when I'm supposed to use dieser, it really feels random at times


It can definitely be confusing, because it all has to do with understanding the gender, number, and case of each noun used! In the linked discussion, "sakasiru" gives a great response and explanation of when to use what! https://forum.duolingo.com/comment/1252496/Use-of-Das-vs-Dies-vs-Diese-Nominativ


How about (This is wine from Spain. )?


Very, very similar. I'm not sure I can articulate the difference, and I'm not sure it is significant at any rate. Suggest it to the moderators.


"This wine comes from spain" is not incorrect!


That's right (though Spain should be capitalised). When you come across instances where you believe there is a problem with the exercise, make sure to report it. The discussion boards can provide insight, clarification etc., but any changes to lesson structure go through the 'report' function.


Duolingo says that The correct solution is This wine comes from Spain but kommt can be confusing because it actually can be interpreted in two ways. Firstly DUolingo suggests kommt must be ignored in present tense therefore it is This wine is from Spain

Learn German in just 5 minutes a day. For free.