Remember: downvoting is for incorrect information being claimed as correct or for disallowed content, not for if someone doesn't understand. This person is asking a legitimate question and should not be downvoted.
Yes, that's because it would make "what year" the topic of the sentence instead of "this year", which in Japanese doesn't make a lot of sense. It's like saying "Is 'what year' this year?" or "Is this year 'what year'?".