"음식은 의미가 있습니다."
Translation:The food is meaningful.
249 CommentsThis discussion is locked.
Lol, at least it means more than "the dog and cat converse in Korean"
It's meaningless to whom not use to cook but tell me what you eat and I will tell you who you are. The doctors in the antique word and in China paid use to say our food should be our medicine. If we eat healthy food we keep the doctor away.
If you look hard enough, you can find meaning in everything. That doesn’t mean it's there though.
Anyeong, I am not learning from this round of basics. Cool, meaningful, delicious, popular? I can't determine which is what here - I am only getting these because of the many times I've gone through - like a parrot. The woman's voice is going too fast and I need it to be broken down i-n-t-o s-l-o-w-e-r- s-y-l-l-a-b-u-l-s. I want to be able to speak to someone in Korean, not just read the alphabet and guess that it is or isn't delicious or meaningful food.
Please give the difference between delicious and meaningful. If I at a Korean restaurant - how would I comment on the food to say that it is good/delicious. Give us everyday language. Komawa
236
I agree. I feel like I should at least understand word order or more grammar but the basics are teaching me random words and sentences ?? I don't even know how to form a proper sentence on my own :(
Try this app lingodeer, it's a language learning app focused on Korean, Japanese and Chinese, in the beginning of each class there is an optional text explaining the part you're about to learn, most of the time the sentence structure and grammar (and you can slow down the audio when you feel like it, and choose between having or not having a romanized version of the word you're learning to help you read).
I love Duolingo, but some of its courses really suck. Have you looked at the Vietnamese course? I spent 17 days in Vietnam, and that course was absolutely useless. I have tried Lingodeer, and it does teach you more, I just got sick of its format. Mango Languages also has a Korean course that is quite useful.
Yes, Duolingo's Vietnamese course makes this course look really, really good by comparison. It's fine to learn "silly" or meaningless sentences to focus on the grammar and structure and vocabulary. It is not fine for it to teach you idioms as if they meant something ("good morning," for instance) when the idioms don't actually exist in the language. It is also not fine to make up rules about which "this" is used in which construction when the language doesn't distinguish between the two words for "this." Also, the Vietnamese course notes mentioned the existence of the tones, showed their markings, explained that they completely change the meaning of words every bit as much as changing a letter would, but somehow fail to mention what "tones" actually are, or give any good pronunciation guide (I forget if it had one at all but if it did, it wasn't useful because it neither gave a description of the actual characteristics of the sound, nor the IPA for the sound like the Korean course has). I recognized pretty quickly that whatever I might have learned from it wouldn't be real Vietnamese, except sometimes from the discussions.
me too i wanted to create sentences on my own but i can't because some of the sentences were not usable in day to day conversation
On the web version of Duolingo that you can access with a browser there are tips and notes with Crowns they are now accessed through a lightbulb button next to the Start button of the skills that have them.
Agreed; a lot of these examples have fast speaking but this one is ridiculous, almost like different audio tracks spliced on top of each other
Yeah i really like duolingo so I was so exited for this korean course but it majorly sucks...it cant be compared to the spanish or french courses at a
Maybe its a gift from a trip to some exotic country? "Please don't eat that; the food is meaningful"
Food is meaningful but movies are meaningless, books are not fun but beds are food... I'm not just learning a language here.
one of the all-time classic duolingo sentences. you can imagine children all over korea eating their breakfasts and telling their mas and pas how meaningful they have found their coco pops
Like most of us, I want lessons where one sentence contains words that are stepping Stones to the next. I was about to give up. Then I decided at BASICS to do this:
-
Pushed through the alphabet because I found romanization was a roadblock.
-
For any other completed sets, I always do the practice.
-
I go online to the Duolingo meet app, and study the tip sheet before starting any new lessons.
-
Writing down the new without using romanization, especially for new words or things I keep getting wrong.
-
Using each "Notes and Tips" from Duolingo online, I try to understand how word order, particles, and how the rules explain which letters to change when forming certain combinations of vowels and consonants.
-
Key: Doing the practices over and over. Then I feel so good to discover how many more I remember.
-
After basics I am working my way up the level ONES so I can get to numbers, food, etc.
-
Made myself slow down for new stuff. And I allow myself to race through practices because that seems to force my mind to search faster.
-
Even though I didn't know the words, I listen and watch Korean TV, movies, BTS and G.O.D., Masked King, YouTubers like BillyGo Korean and Talk To Me in Korean, and anything else I can find like woodworking taught by Koreans. Some but not all have subtitles, mostly English though. Just like any group of people, there are many differences between speakers. like Arabic, Hebrew, English, and Spanish which I have heard from many different countries...there are many flavors. It really helps your ear, and therefore your brain to catch meaningfulness.
Could this also be translated as food has meaning? Correct me if I am wrong, but the verb '있다'/'있어' means to have, would 'food has meaning' be a sufficient answer to this question?
"The food has meaning" should also be accepted, please fix your mistake. Weird sentences like these don't do too well as learning examples.
So can I not split the words and say 음식은 의미있습니다 to mean the same thing?
Perhaps you are not reading the right books, but this sentence is about food. The food in a Passover meal does have meaning. There are specific reasons for the food served then.
It s a comment on the previous sentence saying Books are meaningless, and yet food somehow has more meaning...? I agree that food often can, but books almost always do...so I don't blame the person
- 입니다 ← 이다 (~to be) + ᅟᅠᆸ니다 (formal polite non-past ending)
- 있습니다 ← 있다 (~to have) + 습니다 (formal polite non-past ending)
are you talking about this sentence being said in a normal conversation or your streak
Is it merely a coincidence that so many cultures have customs involving food, or why every major holiday is celebrated with a feast? Food brings people together.
음식 sounds like Japanese 飲食 (飲食) inshoku, but means food and drink or eating and drinking .
I am so confused by this I typed it in like four times and still says it is wrong.
We cannot see what you typed. Next time copy your answer here if you want some help.
When do you say this sentence is real life? "The food is meaningful... ah.".
when you eat a healthy and tasty meal. the people who use to eat ❤❤❤❤❤❤ food can't understand who much the food is meaningfull. The Germans and the AngloSaxons never win a gastronomy contest. The Latin peaple and the Asian people knows how much the food is meanfull and the people who starve understand how the food is meaningfull
Click on the lightbulb button next to the Start button for the Tips and Notes on the web version, which you can get to by Clicking Home button above and then clicking each skill.
For confirmation...의미가 is confirming the food is meaningful...and 있습니다 is saying are/is? Without 있습니다 would it just be food meaningful?
What's with the "있습니다"? Why not just the "anibnida" and "nibnida" we've been learning from the last lesson?
One thing I do not get: some adjectives like 멋 are getting added to the verb directly and do not stand on their own, like: 남자은 멋있습니다 (the man is cool), but other adjectives seem to be a noun like 매력 . So when I use them in a sentence I have to add a particle. So would the sentence: 남자은 매력가 있습니다 be translated to: "the man has charm", if I'd do it directly or what? It confuses me a little bit and I can't really find a solution googling it. So if anyone could tell me something about this mystery, I'd be very grateful.:)
"The food is meaningful" is defo an incorrect sentence like what kind of sentence is that it makes no sense xD
This may or may not be a meaningful sentence, but it and the discussion reveals a deficiency in DuoLingo: Although DuoLingo's approach to learning is effective and better than many methods, it would be even more effective if the examples were things people could actually use. I can guarantee I am NEVER going to ask a Dutch person whether ducks eat cheese!
No, but you will probably remember those words longer than words from an ordinary sentence.
i have a big question: is 가 placed after 의미 because it ends in a vowel? you know because 있습니다 starts with a vowel. This question is killing my mind lmao someone help.
https://www.duolingo.com/comment/26586802$comment_id=27337449
Where there is a choice between 이 and 가…
- Words ending in vowels are always followed by 가: ᅟᅡ, ᅟᅢ, ᅟᅣ, ᅟᅤ, ᅟᅥ, ᅟᅦ, ᅟᅧ, ᅟᅨ, ᅟᅩ, ᅟᅪ, ᅟᅫ, ᅟᅬ, ᅟᅭ, ᅟᅮ, ᅟᅯ, ᅟᅰ, ᅟᅱ, ᅟᅲ, ᅟᅳ, ᅟᅴ, and ᅟᅵ.
- Words ending in consonants are always followed by 이: ᅟᅠᆨ, ᅟᅠᆩ, ᅟᅠᆪ, ᅟᅠᆫ, ᅟᅠᆬ, ᅟᅠᆭ, ᅟᅠᆮ, ᅟᅠᆯ, ᅟᅠᆰ, ᅟᅠᆱ, ᅟᅠᆲ, ᅟᅠᆳ, ᅟᅠᆴ, ᅟᅠᆵ, ᅟᅠᆶ, ᅟᅠᆷ, ᅟᅠᆸ, ᅟᅠᆹ, ᅟᅠᆺ, ᅟᅠᆻ, ᅟᅠᆼ, ᅟᅠᆽ, ᅟᅠᆾ, ᅟᅠᆿ, ᅟᅠᇀ, ᅟᅠᇁ, and ᅟᅠᇂ.
Examples:
- 양파가
- 배가
- 게가
- 뼈가
- 코가
- 열쇠가
- 가루가
- 가위가
- 호랑이가
- 돈이
- 말이
- 밥이
- 그릇이
- 꽃이
- 부엌이
- 밭이
- 삶이
- 값이
It has nothing to do with the verb starting with a vowel. This particular subject marker is used because the word in front of it ends with a vowel.
https://www.duolingo.com/skill/ko/basics-1/tips-and-notes https://www.duolingo.com/skill/ko/basics-2/tips-and-notes https://www.duolingo.com/skill/ko/Descriptive-Verbs/tips-and-notes
These links are not getting you all the way there, so just click on the skill mentioned in the link and then click on the lightbulb button for the Tips and notes for that skill.
Hyperbole. Just that it is a legitimate sentence for a higher level of communication but a bit odd at level 1. I'm trying to memorize high-frequency words like delicious, salty and hot. I suggest retaining it but move it up, perhaps level 3, where learners are ready for such adjs
There is a different word for delicious, please read the comments above. Some food does have meaning. Think of the Passover meal.
Religious and other ceremonial...excellent point. I didn't think of that.
When you have a ceremonial meal, think of Passover. Also, I think that Thanksgiving has meaning as well.
I just keep forgetting that meaningful and meaningless. I am in level 3 in basic2
When you have a ceremonial meal, think of Passover. Also, I think that Thanksgiving has meaning as well.
- 575
i dont understand how food can be meaningfull
Please think of foreign ppl before making such strange sentences >_
When you have a ceremonial meal, think of Passover. Also, I think that Thanksgiving has meaning as well.
- 194
Relatable situation: Can't be bothered to write the same explanation a third time, just copy it.
As an Englishman, I often say to my friends "shall we have some meaningful fish and chips or would you prefer a meaningful macdonalds?
Duo lingo is a very good learning system, repeatedly spolit by rubbish like this
Nonsense, the Passover meal is one with food that is meaningful such as the unleavened bread that was made in a hurry to leave Egypt and Thanksgiving turkey with corn which meant peace and sharing between native Americans and early settlers. No one said that all food is meaningful. This is specific.
Food that is designed to commemorate a past event, so they could be talking about the Passover meal. For example, there is no leavening in the bread and no yeast, because the Jews needed to leave Egypt quickly and did not have time to wait for the bread to rise.
- 821
Food can never be meaningful, I'm sorry. It can be tasty, delicious, good, bad, but not meaningful
Nonsense, the Passover meal is one with food that is meaningful such as the unleavened bread that was made in a hurry to leave Egypt and Thanksgiving turkey with corn which meant peace and sharing between native Americans and early settlers. No one said that all food is meaningful. This is specific.
No, it works, but though most food does not have meaning, some meals do have significance, the food used for the Passover meal has a direct link to history. Also, the Christmas yule log cake represents the actual yule log.
Just came here to see where everyone's ideas were going to go about this sentence and I saw A LOT.
how can food be meaningful! man! I'm starting to hate this app!!!!just kidding I love this app more than anything.
I guess this sentence is inspired by eatjin shows. Seokjin will be proud of this sentence! ㅋㅋㅋ
There is nothing wrong with the grammar here, but rules are different in each language.
If someone brings you food for a reason then it has meaning: meaningful. So it may sound weird to some people but in a culture that appreciates food buying or giving food to someone has a special meaning. This is big in Korean culture.
The food served at Passover for example which included unleavened bread that the Jews ate on their way out of Egypt.
What food is meaningless but how? Many people can't eat food and you are telling it meaningless
The sentence above is "The food is meaningful." Nonsense, the Passover meal is one with food that is meaningful such as the unleavened bread that was made in a hurry to leave Egypt and Thanksgiving turkey with corn which meant peace and sharing between native Americans and early settlers. No one said that all food is meaningful. This is specific.
Instead of 의미가 Duolingo could just put us to say 처 음식은 맛있어요. Would be more useful and..."meaningful", imo
이 책은 의미김있나 This book is meaningful I tried to make a sentence, is the grammar correct?
If it is meaningful then it might be important, but that is a different word when translating.
- 404
"Meaningful" is an awkward descriptive for "food". I have yet to actually hear anyone use it for food. I think Duolingo should use a different word in this case.
Most food is not meaningful, but certain celebrations use food which do symbolize history: the yule log, the Thanksgiving turkey and the Passover feast.
- 404
I agree with your statement. For myself, this particular verbiage does not come to mind as a stand alone statement. This is what threw me off. Thank you again; this discussion was meaningful to me!
Thanksgiving turkey and Passover meal refer back to historical events. Christmas log cake refers back to a real log in the fireplace and does also have meaning. Scroll down for more.
Look for the "there is" verb. If it's "there is (isseubnida)" it's meaningful, if it's "there isn't (eobsubnida--someone check my spelling)" it's meaningless.
I am forever a foodie and for me i agree that a food is meaningfull and can make me even cry if its good
Wonderful, but food is a mass quantity so we say just "food" without "a".
- 251
This is what RM would have said if he was a Chef ..oh my bad , he must have said it anyway
Really? The food is meaningful? C'mon duo, give us meaningful words that we would actually use!!!! That is why I am thinking of not renewing!!!!
I am wondering, maybe the food was made for a birthday party or something like that lol
