1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: Spanish
  4. >
  5. "Yo toco el violín y él la fl…

"Yo toco el violín y él la flauta."

Translation:I play the violin and he plays the flute.

March 12, 2013



Ok, this sentence was just plain ole sneaky. I didn't see "he plays" at all.


'tocar' = both 'touch' and 'to play a musical instrument'


I think Xandra meant the missing verb for el in Spanish.


Why is 'I play violin and he plays flute' wrong? Perfectly good english I would have thought.


Yes, that's a correct translation. Report it.


I'm a little confused. In sentences like these, how does the second subject (he) have an invisible verb? Is there an explanation regarding this?


Even in English, that makes some sense. "I play the violin, and he the flute". Probably not as common, though.


I did not know, Spanish says it like this, but I know German has the same. For the second person the verb can be dropped.


This was a good Spanish sentence for us learners. It highlighted one of the ways that Spanish lets you elide repetition where English usually doesn't. But we also do similar stuff. Like in the sentence "I don't like to light firecrackers in my mouth, but he does." Non-English speakers might wonder what exactly it is that he is doing, because most of the last clause of that sentence is invisible.


It was pretty hard to hear the 'el'


that was a crafty one... sneaking a "he" in there along with a "the"..


It's supposed to be "Yo toco el violín y él toca la flauta". If in english you say "I play the violin, and he the flute." then it's politically incorrect.


politically incorrect? er....


The translation given in my lesson omits the word "plays" which is confusing for a learner because "I play the violin and he the flute." is not commonly used.

Learn Spanish in just 5 minutes a day. For free.