"I hear screams."

Translation:J'entends des cris.

November 16, 2017

This discussion is locked.

[deactivated user]

    Why not "j'écoute des cris"?


    J'écoute = I listen

    J'entends = I hear


    "Écouter" means "to listen".

    Here is a post by someone called Remy describing the difference between "écouter" and "entendre".


    why is "les cris" NOT acceptable? when is les or des to be used?


    I think it might be because the screams that are heard are not tied to specific people, they are in the distance and from an unknown source. "Des" creates more vagueness than "les".

    I might be wrong but that's how I see it.


    when there is no article - a or the - at all, something like "any" is assumed. I hear screams does not equal I hear the screams, but rather, I hear some screams. Do you hear any screams? Yes, I hear some screams.


    Both answers are great for the des! Thanks!!

    I think that the English error arrives from the actual word choice process [lol]... i.e. approximate somewhat wrong e.g. J'entends cris. (No, needs an article) J'entends des cris. (No, not unknown (as to what the prevalence/makeup of a heard scream is anyway (indefinite))) J'entends les cris (No, not know (as to what is causing the scream (definite) although screams are fairly certainly screams unto themselves (les)) ...[lol]

    So back to simplicity and the base that indefinite is the lean and tendency of French, unless otherwise stated. "J'entends des cris." I hear [some] screams. Indeed.

    I won't argue the losing battle for the unexpressed/unsaid/un-definite "les..." https://books.google.ca/books?id=1us8AAAAIAAJ=PA17=PA17=french+preferes+indefinite+to+definite+speech=bl=oOVu6MkoHf=uDHrLyQySSdBqWetooK2bP_z6Xs=en=X=0ahUKEwi42oKui8naAhUM7IMKHWUPCUsQ6AEIejAG#v=onepage=french%20preferes%20indefinite%20to%20definite%20speech=false

    I think the link is likely not working elsewhere in the world, whatever... It was only to an obscure book entitled "Style in the French Novel, by Stephen Ullmann" Referencing Page 17ish forward - Published 1964, Printed 1957 (University Paper First) [lol] Oh what a journey = Oh quel voyage ! :-|


    why not je oui des cris?

    Learn French in just 5 minutes a day. For free.