"We have a little black dog."
Translation:我们有一只黑色的小狗。
27 CommentsThis discussion is locked.
Actually, that's what is commonly being used in English, too. People say it's a 'small black dog' and not it's a 'black small dog'.
"我们有一只黑色小狗" was marked wrong for not having the 的 , the answer being given as "我们有一只黑色的小狗". While I can see that's correct, is it absolutely necessary to have the 的 in there. I thought it could be omitted.
It can only be omitted in some cases. Most importantly:
- For possessives: 的 is optional if the possessor is a personal pronoun and the possessee is either a person with close personal relationship to the personal pronoun (e.g. 我(的)妈妈) or an institution that the personal pronoun is part of (e.g. 我们(的)公司)
- for adjective attributes: 的 is optional if the adjective is only one syllable and not modified by any adverbs (so 黑(的)狗 or 黑狗, but not *黑色狗). Also, if there are two one-syllable adjectives, I would use 的 at least on the one that is further away from the noun (in other words, I think 黑小狗 sounds a bit odd; I prefer 黑(色)的小狗).
Excellent ! Thanks AbunPang. I knew the rule for possessives, but I didn't know that rule for adjectives. Good to know. Sounds and feels right too.
If the adjective is more than one character, I think 的 is required.
Can't you omit the 色的？我们有一只黑小狗 or would that change the meaning to an "evil dog" or something like that?
85
小狗 is also puppy, right? Would it be correct to use that translation here? Is there a way to know which is meant ("puppy" or "small dog"), other than context?
I was about to write 我们有一只黑色和小的狗 idk if that's gramatically correct or not, if someone can help me and say yes or no
- 343
"We have a black puppy" is accepted for the reverse translation. They remark "We have a little black dog." is another correct translation.
Google and deepl both translate "We have a little black dog" to "我们有一只小黑狗" and "We have a black puppy" to "我们有一只黑色的小狗" Maybe "小狗" is a fixed expression for "puppy"? See archchinese (https://www.archchinese.com/chinese_english_dictionary.html?find=%E5%B0%8F%E7%8B%97)
Where does 小 need to go in this sentence? I used "我们有一只小黑色的狗" but was marked wrong.
- 320
I'm also curious, although the discussion above suggests that if you could put 小 first, it would be "一只小的黑狗“.
The accepted answer here is useful https://chinese.stackexchange.com/questions/9190/what-are-the-rules-in-chinese-for-adjective-order-when-multiple-adjectives-descr
I don't have a chinese keyboard installed on this device so I'm afraid it's pinyin only. Adjectives with 'de' must be further away than those without. So 'heisede' must come before 'xiaogou'. (And as a single syllable adjective 'xiao' does not need 'de'.)
Who downvotes these questions?? (it was at -1)
A perfectly valid doubt (which I shared, and the course's tips say nothing about). Thanks to it and MrC314159's answer (which was at 0), I leave knowing a bit more than when I came.
why can't i say this without 色的, like "我们有一只黑小狗"? Or, for that matter "我们有一只小黑狗"?