- Forum >
- Topic: Chinese >
- "我不能说中文，好在我的朋友可以。"
"我不能说中文，好在我的朋友可以。"
Translation:I can't speak Chinese, luckily my friend can.
38 Comments
能说？ not 会说？ Never heard 能 when talking abour knowing languages. Is there a difference?
I learned that 会is for skills you learn/practice. Whereas 能 is for literal, physical ability to do something. By those rules, I agree with you that languages should use 会。
966
A: ability in the sense of “know how to” (会 is more common than 能)
B: permission/request (use 能 or 可以)
C: possibility (use 能 or 可以)
D: permission not granted (use 不可以)
E: impossibility (use 不能)
According to this website, 不能说 is correct for A and possibly E also.
https://resources.allsetlearning.com/chinese/grammar/Comparing_%22hui,%22_%22neng,%22_%22keyi%22
Absolutely agree. From now I can not trust Duolingo in learning Chinese.
I learned that 会 is used when talking about an ability you have required, ex. a language. 能 is used when talking about ability caused by external factors you cannot control.
- 648
i could be wrong, but my understanding is that in this sentence, 能 would be saying you are not permitted to speak chinese, or that some circumstance prevented you, as the other commenter explained. so yes, 会 is the correct choice, as far as i know.
the character 能 means the ability to do something, much like the verb étre in French
I know this isn't 中文, but...
Just want to point out that the french "être" does not imply ability. The verb "être" is the verb "to be" in english.
Absolutely agree. From now I can not trust Duolingo in learning Chinese.
"I can't speak Mandarin; it's good that my friends can" should be accepted.
Why do most of these not let me use "but" to combine the sentences? The comma seems to imply you should be able to.
"But" would be ok for this sentence. Some of the other questions do not really work as one sentence in English.
This seems to go against the all the chinese translationd of "can" i know: for skills, 会 ought to be used, and 能 and 可以 are for capabilities and permitted actions respectively... please inform
Yeah, same thought here and I think other people in the comments agree... "不能" sounds like something is preventing you from speaking Chinese x) Like, "I'm too drunk right now, so I 不能 speak Chinese" or "I just broke up with my Chinese boyfriend, and Chinese reminds me of him too much, so I 不能 speak Chinese" xD
How about "I cannot speak Chinese, so it is a good thing that my friend can."
In English..Luckily my friend can or Luckily my does. Mean the same thing.
Why is my answer "I am unable to speak.." wrong? Isn't "unable "interchangeable with " i can't" or i am not able?. Also, i have reported many times with the option that many of the words throughout the course have warped audio.
中文 can refer to Mandarin but it it typically refers to all of the major Chinese languages spoken by the Han Chinese peoples (the majority ethnic group in the PRC/Taiwan) often in written form. When referring to Mandarin itself you'll more typically see things like 普通话 (pǔtōnghuà).
So, the program was correct to reject your translation.
"I cannot speak Chinese, it's good that my friend can." should be accepted. In another exercise about a competition and rain "it's good that" is accepted...
I would like to add a note to the comment from Jason137255 that 会 means "to be able to" in the sense of physical or mental abilities (e.g. to be table to speak a language, swim, drive a car), while 能 means "to be able to" in the sense that you have the opportunity to do it, nothing is preventing you from doing it (so it's possible to 会 but not 能 to do something).
Example 1:
-
我不可以开车 - I can't drive (because I'm not allowed to, I don't have a driving license)
-
我不能开车去那边 - I can't drive there (because my mom has my car; because I drank alcohol)
-
我不会开车 - I can't drive (I don't have the ability to drive a car, I haven't learned it)
Example 2:
-
我不可以喝酒 - I am not allowed to drink (because I'm under 18)
-
我不能喝酒 - I can't drink (because I just took some special medicine)
-
我不会喝酒 - I can't drink alcohol (I'm bad at drinking, I get drunk very easily)
Hope that helps :)
Not quite. According to the Chinese Grammar Wiki (https://resources.allsetlearning.com/chinese/grammar/Comparing_%22hui%22_%22neng%22_%22keyi%22):
"Sometimes they are explained as: 会 means "know how to," 能 means "to be able to," and 可以 means "to have permission to." Actually, they overlap somewhat."
It goes into further details but given what is mentioned in the article I would side with using 能 here.
I sort of feel like this is the difference between English's "Can I" vs "May I".
And yes, it's for sure quite strange to use one and then another in the second half of the sentence O_o As I commented above it sounds like "I can't speak Chinese [at the moment], good thing my friend is allowed to" :D
- 819
Wow. I already had questions when I went into this discussion. Now I have ten more! Firstly, according to every breakdown posted above, and also this video,(https://chinesepod.com/lessons/all-about-can-能-neng会-hui可以-keyǐ) where I first learned all this, "可以" doesn't make sense at the end of the Chinese sentence. I didn't even SEE the 会/能 divide at the beginning! Thanks, upstream posters! So our Chinese sentence translates more as "I'm not physically able to speak chinese right now, good thing my friend has permission".
ALSO! What's up with using "中文"? I know there are subtle differences, but I thought "文" referred more to spoken language. Should it not be "汉语"?
From how I was told:
語 just means language
話 means language in a spoken sense, not really including grammar.
文 means language with all it's "scholarly" attributes like grammar, spelling, punctuation etc. and maybe even poetry or calligraphy.
For example, if you tell someone you know 德文, it feels like you've studied German, had classes and exams and stuff. If you say you know some 德國話, it sounds like you've lived in Germany or visited and learned two words or maybe several sentences, or maybe you can actually speak but don't know how to write. Also, a video showing someone speak German would more likely be labeled "德國話" because we're showing speaking; and if it's like an online course or a Youtube teacher it would be 德語 or 德文. Language courses in the university are called "文". The article in Wikipedia about German language is called 德語.
(this is all "reporting" how it is in Taiwan)
Some language do not have a 文. For example, 台灣話 is always 話, it doesn't have a written language. Dialects are 話 - 廣東話, 四川話 (Cantonese is not really a dialect of Mandarin, but you know what I mean, local languages)
- 819
Thanks. That's kinda what I thought the distinction was. So if you say you can't speak 中文, you're kinda saying you haven't studied the language formally, whereas not speaking 汉语 is more about not being able to converse in an informal sense?
Well... I think the distinction is more clear when you say you CAN one of those things, but when you say you can't, it's like, if you can't one you can't another xD Dunno. I don't feel much difference between saying I don't speak 中文 or 汉语. Not a native speaker though :) (lived in Taiwan and learned Chinese for 6 years)
You forgot "fortunately", "thankfully", "by a stroke of luck" etc..
The other hundreds of learners here will come up with a few dozen more I'm sure, to help us all improve our Chinese. ;-)
Can you use 幸亏 ? I've never seen anyone use 好在before Duolingo. Is that a region thing?
I would translate it more like "I'm not able to speak Chinese, good thing my friend is allowed to" :D
