1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: German
  4. >
  5. "Eine Frau isst einen Apfel."

"Eine Frau isst einen Apfel."

Translation:A woman is eating an apple.

March 18, 2013


Sorted by top post


German has cases, so the articles (der/die/das und ein/eine) change form depending on what is being done to the object. I think this is genetive, but I'm not sure. It's something we should learn about later.


Somebody later in the comments mentioned accusative, so I put the wrong cas sorry.


How about pronouncation between 'ist' (sein) and 'isst' (eats ) correctly?


How can we know the difference between Eine: A and Eine: One?


No difference.


In English the "a" can be replaced with one without changing the meaning.' She eats one apple' and 'she eats an apple' mean essentially the same thing, it's just when you want to put emphasis on 'one'. You can put emphasis with which word you stress in german. 'Sie isst einen Apfel' 'Sie ist EINEN Apfel'


why is it not den Apfel over here? Its masculine, so shouldn't it be den? or is den only for plurals? Oh god all these rules are confusing damn


the = definite article

You're being asked to translate an indefinite article (a/an).

If the English sentence was "A woman is eating the apple", then you would be right; it would be "Eine Frau isst den Apfel".


Can I say "Ein Frau isst einen Apfel"? or do I have to add a "E" to the "Ein"? which will make it "Eine".


You need the e on the end.


Why do they put isst not esst ???


Eine Frau = a woman

When a woman (eine Frau) is the subject, the verb gets conjugated the same as though he/she/it (er/sie/es) was the subject.

The conjugation of the verb essen for er/sie/es is "isst".
Er isst.
Sie isst.
Es isst.

"Esst" is the conjugation for the subject "ihr" (you, informal, plural).
See this conjugation chart:


when i use a insted of an it says i'm wrong when a is a choice


An is used before words which are pronounced with a vowel and a before words which are pronounced with thw consonant.


What does this have to do with the genitive case?


Simple: nothing. There's none, and no one mentioned the genitive case before you asked. "Eine Frau" is nominative (genitive would be: "einer Frau"), and "einen Apfel" is accusative (genitive: "eines Apfels").


I think I asked about the genitive case because it was a genitive lesson and this non-genitive sentence appeared out of nowhere.


Ah, I see. Well, Duo is doing that quite frequently. Don't worry. :)


What's the difference between " Die Frau isst einen Apfel" and Eine Frau isst einen Apfel ". Why " eats " and " is eating " ?


Die Frau = The woman (definite) / Eine Frau = a woman (indefinite). Both "eats" and "is eating" are valid translations of "isst" because in German there is no continuous form.


Geez how to pronounce apfel? Help


Hey, a woman eat an apple is the same as a woman is eating an apple, no difference on it. Eine Frau isst einen apfel


How do you differentiate between isst(2nd person singular) and isst(3rd person singular)?


You can't if you're looking at the verb only. The subject makes the difference. If there's a "du" then it's 2nd person singular, otherwise it's 3rd person singular. There are more verbs like this: vergessen, *fressen, hassen, *lassen, prassen, *fassen, *passen, hissen, *missen, *pissen (vulgar!), *beißen, *heißen, *reißen, *scheißen (vulgar!), spleißen, *gießen, *schießen, *schließen, genießen, niesen, vermiesen, *reisen, *preisen, *weisen. But not: wissen, müssen (they're irregular: du weißt, er/sie weiß etc.) Does anybody have more of these?


I wrote A woman eats an apple But Duolingo said it is incorrect ... Why is it so??


It doesn't have an "eats" ,it has an "eat" option , so you have to choose the other form of present :"is eating" .


I didn't have a choice. I had to type my answer in and it was still marked incorrect.


In the word box, there isn't "eating" choice, so this is wrong,


Why is it "...einen Apfel" instead of "eine Apfel". (She is eating an apple)


The word Apfel is grammatically masculine.

It's also the direct object of the verb "eat", so it has to be in the accusative case.

The masculine accusative form of ein is einen.

That is why it is einen Apfel.

eine would be feminine -- for example, if she were eating a tomato (eine Tomate).

For a neuter noun, it would be ein -- for example, if she were eating a horse (ein Pferd).


why cant I say a apple why do I have to say "1" apple? whats the difference?


Instead of "a apple", you should write "an apple".

Words that start with a vowel sound (such as "apple") take the indefinite article "an" in English.

Unfortunately, Duo's corrections are not always as good as a human's in terms of finding "what the learner probably meant".


Eine as in one and eine as in a is super confusing!


it said a instead of an


Tell me when we use "ein Apfel" and when we use "einen Apfel "


The short answer:

  • ein Apfel when it's the subject (the thing that is or does something)
  • einen Apfel when it's the direct object (the thing that gets something done to it)


My anwser to this question was: A woman is eating an apple. But he says its wrong?


Why isn't it "Eine Frau isst ein Apfel?"

I don't get why in some sentences it's "ein Apfel" and in some sentences it's "einen Apfel?"


When the apple is doing something (Der/ein Apfel fällt - The apple falls) then you use der (the) or ein (a/an). When something is being done to the apple (Er isst den/einen Apfel He eats/is eating the/an apple) then you use den/einen. When words do different things in a sentence (acting, being acted on, receiving actions, owning things) they are said to be in different "cases" in German.

The man eats (The man is doing the action: Nominative Case - Der Mann. Der Mann isst.

I eat the man (the man is being acted on: Accusative Case - den Mann . Ich esse den Mann.

I gave it to the man (the man is the indirect recipient of whatever "it" is: Dative Case - dem Mann) Ich gab es dem Mann.

The man's hat (the man possesses/owns something: Genitive Case - des Mannes) Der Hut des Mannes.

In time you will learn what function a word performs in the sentence, and will know which "case" to use.


the woman is an apple!


It says isst not ist, and einen Apfel not ein Apfel


i know, it's just funny how it sounds the same


except for the ein/einen apfel


And even that sounds pretty similar in spoken German. (And many Germans who are not good at grammar will get it wrong in writing.)


Difference between is eating and eats?


In English, we use present continuous (e.g. "she is eating") for an action that is happening now, and the present simple (e.g. "she eats") for a repeated or habitual action.

Standard German does not make this distinction and would use sie isst in both cases.




Because Apfel is masculine and because it's the direct object of the verb essen (to eat), so it's in the accusative case.

einen is the masculine accusative form of the indefinite article, so that's the form we need in this sentence.


Why is eating instead of eats


Why is eating instead of eats

Both translations are possible.

Learn German in just 5 minutes a day. For free.