"Der Abend ist lang, die Nacht ist kurz."

Translation:The evening is long, the night is short.

February 1, 2018

This discussion is locked.


And full of terrors.


Is this an idiom?


You were awake for a long time, you did not sleep for a long time.


really? how does it mean this? I don't understand.


Not in German, it's just one of those DL sentences that are somewhat weird...


It is a line from a German language short story.

I don't know if it is relevant but the characters in this particular short story are unusual or are in unusual circumstances.

The line has nice ring to it in English. Makes you wonder .....is it that the evenings seem really long or that it is the nights that seem really short. Or maybe both seem unusual for some reason. What is going on in the speaker's life that he feels this way?


Welche Kurzgeschichte?


WeiƟ ich auch nicht


Hello Northernguy, Since you are clearly well versed in German, perhaps you could also answer this question? (I apologize in advance; it does contain an awful pun.) In another post, someone asked why on says "Wie lange dauert es?" and not "Wie lang dauert es?" The moderator said that "lange" means "(for) a long time," while "lang" means "long" in a spatial dimension. If that is correct, that why would "lang" be used here and not "lange?" I understand that this phrase comes from a well-known German short story, and it is certainly the writer's right to play with the language, but it seems strange to be so by-the-book in one case, and so whatever goes in another.
Your thoughts? Kara


Just a guess, but I think only "lange" is an adverb, while "lang"plus different suffixes are adjectives. English is "poor in morphology" so all these words are the same in English... On the other hand, "longly" does sound weird.


"The night is brief " is wrong? Why?


Too narrow a usage for short. Brief always means short but short doesn't always mean brief. The night may seem short but it is always the same length depending on the time of year, so it isn't actually brief.


Because that mean short bit this is wrong


Near the artic circle at certain times of the year?


Do you always need an article for Abend and Nacht in German? And if so, would it be appropriate to translate the sentence as "Evenings are long, nights are short"?


Is this an idiom?


You need a conjunction to connect these independant clauses, right?


Not really. Asyndetic coordination is possible in both German and English.


I think it's a matter of style. You could use a semicolon, colon or full stop instead of the comma, or you could stand by your comma splice and call it asyndeton. I'm a mere native English speaker and not a stylist so I pass on this one!


"Die Nacht" or "der Nacht". How does one know what to use?


It's case. "Die" is the feminine nominative. It's used when the noun is the subject of the sentence. "Die" is also the feminine accusative, which is the direct object, or the object that the action/verb is performed on. "Der" is used for feminine dative nouns, as well as masculine nominative nouns. The dative case is used for indirect objects, which is the object indirectly affected by the verb. Also, there are dative propositions, like "mit," "zu," etc., which automatically trigger the dative case, no matter what.

Ex.: "I gave the bottle to the mother."

'I' is the subject/nominative, 'the bottle' is the direct object/accusative, and 'the mother' is the indirect object/dative. In German, it would be:

"Ich habe der Mutter die Flasche gegeben."

(Note the switched word order: 'der Mutter/the mother' comes before 'die Flasche/the bottle.' Also, the 'to' in the English sentence doesn't need to be translated here since it's implied.)

Sorry for the long and detailed and complicated answer. German has a very intricate system. I'm just grateful that English got rid of this system a long time ago.

  • 2502

Is this an idiom or stock saying in German? It has that feel.


Like chponge and Markqz, I would like to know if this is a German idiom. Any native speakers out there?


Das hat sie gesagt


The night actual lasts longer than evenings.


Die Nacht ist lang und voller Schrecken.


Why does the microphone turn off when i attempted to say the phrase. Stupid app hqppens alot, WHY?

Learn German in just 5 minutes a day. For free.