Why can't we say, "Are you wearing the new dress today?" As a native English speaker, it irritates me all this "putting on" when we would say "wear." We would use "putting on" for a situation where you are trying to encourage someone to try on a new dress or wear a specific dress they are hesitant to wear. Ex. Are you putting on the new dress today? (Implying we haven't gotten you to in the past but we want you to.) If you just want to know what someone is wearing you would say, "Are you wearing the new dress today?" Can we translate ponerse "wear" or is there another verb?
They definitely do. But Duolingo has frequently used them interchangeably, to the point that it's trained me to use "wear" in its clothing examples. And "Are you wearing the new dress today?" would be the more natural English statement.
03/26/2019: I wrote it that way, and it was accepted.
I very much commend your willingness to reflect and consider that you might be wrong, as compared to the sort of linguistic dogmatism that one frequently finds here. And may I say that my mother, who was from Birmingham, UK, would quite naturally say 'Are you going to put that on?' or 'What are you putting on tonight?' or 'Why don't you put your new shirt on?' etc. I don't know to give out lingots, and anyway I need all the ones I've got!
Tú (with accent mark) is a subject pronoun. It's used to say who is doing the action. Often, the subject is unnecessary in Spanish, since the ending on the verb gives it away. This is the case in this sentence.
Tu (no accent) is a possessive pronoun, translating to "your" in English. It is used to say that something belongs to you.
Te is an object pronoun. It represents the direct object, indirect object, or reflexive object.
- I love you. (Yo) te quiero. (direct object)
- He gives you the gift. (Él) te da el regalo. (indirect object)
- Are you taking a shower? ¿(Tú) te duchas? (reflexive object)
In this sentence, the "te" is a reflexive pronoun as part of the verb "ponerse" (to put on).
Thanks for this explanation! I think it's useful to point out that ponerse is a reflexive verb. Correct me if I'm wrong (my understanding comes from french, which also has similar reflexive verbs). This means that some verbs, like ducharse (to shower oneself) and ponerse (to put on oneself) will always have those object pronouns in front of it. So the conjugations go: yo me ducho, tú te duchas... and yo me pongo, tú te pones etc.
Another interesting point is that the infinitive "ponerse" has the word "se" at the end. This means that the sentence "Pedro quiere ponerse su abrigo rojo" is correct, but not "Pedro quiere se ponerse su abrigo rojo." You would, however, say "Pedro se pone su abrigo rojo," and not "Pedro pone su abrigo rojo."
I agree. They should give you an option to disable the streak and combo point functionality so that you don't have to deal with the "winning" and "losing" of points. Once they gamified getting every answer correct, they made winning points an implied objective, and normal learning mistakes became failures that cost you points. Maybe that motivates some people, but I loathe it with a passion! I've learned to mostly not look at the points, so that I don't get frustrated and depressed when I lose something that I didn't even care about before. But having to consciously blot something out of my awareness is not nearly as pleasant as it was when I could just learn rather than win/lose points in some obscure competition.
As I say, I'm sure that whole points thing works for some people, I just wish it was customizable and you could turn it off it you didn't like it. At least they gave us a way to turn off the leaderboard, I was grateful for that!
Yep. As I go along, I am realizing more and more that Duolingo is a game first and a language-learning app second. And it is an English-language game and app (as opposed to other courses that use Spanish as the working language as much as possible).
I have learned a new language twice by immersion, and it was a tortuous process filled with mistakes (and natives laughing out loud at some of the mistakes). You have to be prepared to just go in there and talk and let the mistakes happen. Avoiding mistakes hinders learning.
I'm convinced that Duolingo is a valuable learning tool, but one has to use it effectively.... by not fearing mistakes, and also by using outside resources, especially a second course to teach grammar, which Duo minimizes... assuming you want to learn the language. If you don't mind the gamey framework and don't actually need to learn functional Spanish, that is different and you can continue with Duo and have fun.
Myself, I think I am somewhere in the middle. I want to learn Spanish, but have not actually committed to being able to speak it by a certain time. This might change. If it does, I'm pretty sure my learning strategies will change.
The only way you can opt out of the leagues or leader board is to make your profile private. That's like becoming a recluse. You can't see how your friends are doing. As for the leagues, I recommend ignoring them or getting up to the level you're happy with (diamond is the top) and then just make a point of staying in the top 45 out of 50 each week. There are usually at least 5 people who for whatever reason aren't doing a lot of Duolingo in a given week. It's a lot easier to stay in diamond than to get there.
Instead of taking the game and points seriously, take learning Spanish seriously. Buy a good Spanish grammar book. Complete the learning tree in Duolingo. Listen to things like The News in Slow Spanish. Join or start a Duolingo Spanish group, where you meet and talk in Spanish. Watch videos and films in Spanish with English subtitles, then with Spanish subtitles, and finally with no subtitles.
Happiness is having a goal you care about and seeing yourself moving toward it. El español es un idioma hermoso.
Technically, "Will you put on ..." is future tense.
Duolingo accepts "Are you putting on the new dress today?"
But it rejects "Are you putting the new dress on today?
Please always report that your answer should be accepted, if you're sure. This helps you and others by helping Duolingo get better.
EDIT: Case in point: Duolingo now accepts "Are you putting the new dress on today."
What is the sense of "Te pones el vestido nuevo hoy" to a native Spanish speaker? Is it only the English sense "Are you putting on the new dress today" or does it also have the English sense of "Are you wearing the new dress today?"
Or, is there a separate Spanish word we use for "wear" instead of "put on?"
The female Duolingo speaker slurs her words not to get to the fastest speed possible, but just to portray the real way Spanish speakers speak: depending on the region, various sounds are often dropped (the s at the ends of words, for example), or vowel sounds blur together. Duolingo is preparing us for real Spanish speakers.
- as a native English/American speaker, I regularly asked " are you putting on....?" To me, it implies the whatever, has not been put on, that you're not sure what will be worn/chosen.
- Wearing seems to imply it's already put on or being shown to me as a choice.
- If the specifics of the language irks someone, maybe this isn't the program for you. Go with it - learn that DUO uses pons to mean "put on" at this point.
Well, I don't think we've learned much besides present tense yet. All we know how to say thus far is "are you putting on." The only tense we've learned besides present is the simple future, where you add "ir" for "I'm going to ..." (so, "voy a ponerme un vestido elegante").
OK, tony, here is my best take on this.
Are you putting on the new dress today? =
¿Te pones el vestido nuevo hoy?
These are present progressive and present respectively and are per Duo's sentences.
Did you put on the new dress today? =
¿Te pusiste el vestido nuevo hoy?
In English it is the past tense and in Spanish it is the preterite.
Then "Will you put" is future. I don't know the Spanish future yet, but SpanishDict says "Te pondrás".
(I also have trouble with tenses.)