https://www.duolingo.com/MlleNadine4

Qui as a subject in a question with inversion or est-ce que

When qui is used as the subject of a question, can you still use inversion and est-ce que?

So like in the sentence: "Who has a pencil?" who is the subject, so with inversion, would you treat it like any other pronoun and invert it as, "A-qui un crayon?"

<pre> "Who has a pencil?" with est-ce que, can you still place it in front of the subject if the subject is who? Would it be, "Est-ce que qui a un crayon?" </pre>

Merci beaucoup!!

March 26, 2018

4 Comments


https://www.duolingo.com/relox84

The simplest way to phrase it is "Qui a un crayon ?" which will work in all contexts regardless of formality.

With "est-ce que/est-ce qui", you have to put the interrogative pronoun before it if there is one:
"Qui est-ce qui a un crayon ?"

(note that 'est-ce qui' is used here instead of 'est-ce que' because it is the subject of the sentence)

In the colloquial language, "qui est-ce" may be replaced by "c'est qui", giving:
"C'est qui qui a un crayon ?"

Note that these two wordings, especially the latter, are usually considered very unelegant because of the repetition of the word 'qui'

March 26, 2018

https://www.duolingo.com/Noabji

Est-ce que can almost always be translated to "is it that." Is it that who has a crayon doesn't make sense. You can just say "Qui a un crayon"

March 26, 2018

https://www.duolingo.com/Qwl8143

In these types of "est-ce que" questions, it is mandatory that a subject comes after "est-ce que." Therefore, "Qui est-ce que [verbe]" is not an acceptable clause.

As such, these questions must either be formulated without the use of "est-ce que" or without the use of "qui."

*Quelqu'un means somebody, but often replaces "qui" in questions of this sort that are not inversions or "est-ce que" formations.

Who has a pencil? = Qui/Quelqu'un a un crayon ?

Who has a pencil? = Est-ce que quelqu'un a un crayon ?

Who would be willing to take out the trash? = Qui/Quelqu'un serait disponible à sortir la poubelle ?

Who would be willing to take out the trash? = Est-ce que quelqu'un serait disponible à sortir la poubelle ?

March 26, 2018

https://www.duolingo.com/Cleanthe3

Beside the correct grammar rules (that some people explain very well) you can hear sometimes "qui est-ce qui ..?" . "qui est-ce qui a pris le crayon ? " " qui est-ce qui a fait ça ? "

Well..no need to say that it is bad french , it's not good grammar at all but you can hear it . It's more complicated to say , but weirdly the spoken language doesn't always evolve the simplest way...

March 26, 2018
Learn French in just 5 minutes a day. For free.