"Un joli jardin ensoleillé est si agréable !"
Translation:A lovely and sunny garden is so pleasant!
13 CommentsThis discussion is locked.
Why is "agreeable" rejected?
1.. enjoyable and pleasurable; pleasant.
"a cheerful and agreeable companion"
synonyms: pleasant, pleasing, enjoyable, pleasurable, nice, to one's liking, appealing, charming, delightful
Origin: Old French agreer / agreable --> agreeable (late Middle English)
Why force us to use "pleasant" when the most direct and accurate translation is simply the Engish spelling of "agréable"? Why make learning French vocabulary harder than it actually is?
Henry David Thoreau, Walden:
The forest has never so good a setting, nor is so distinctly beautiful, as when seen from the middle of a small lake amid hills which rise from the water's edge; for the water in which it is reflected not only makes the best foreground in such a case, but, with its winding shore, the most natural and agreeable boundary to it.
Encyclopaedia Brittanica, Belfast:
The country surrounding Belfast is agreeable and picturesque, whether along the shores of the Lough or towards the girdle of hills to the west; and is well wooded and studded with country seats and villas.
Encyclopaedia Brittanica, Sucre, Bolivia:
Its elevation, 8839 ft., gives it an exceptionally agreeable climate.
Encyclopaedia Britannica, Arboretum:
In this more general respect, an arboretum or woodland affords shelter, improves local climate, renovates bad soils, conceals objects unpleasing to the eye, heightens the effect of what is agreeable and graceful, and adds value, artistic and other, to the landscape.
I could go on for hours. Agreeable is a thoroughly appropriate translation of agréable in the DL sentence above. Sometimes DL is just wrong. The appropriate thing to do is acknowledge the error and move on.
Why devote so much energy into forcing this?
If George, so devoted to we learners of french, is telling us that the context elevates pleasant over agreeable as a definition, why not embrace a different way of thinking aka a french way of thinking?
Part of the philosophical benefit of learning a second language is diving into a new way of thinking. Come on in! The water is lovely!