The word "está" is used to describe location. One exception to this rule is when you are speaking of a specific event like a party: Soy a la fiesta de cumpleaños de mi abuelo/I am at my grandfather's birthday party.
Something that i was taught that helps is DOCTOR and PLACE
This is when you use "ser" As in soy, eres, es, somos, and en.
Date Origin Ccharacteristic Time Occupation Relationship
This is where you use "estar" Such as estoy, estàs, està, estamos, and estàn.
Position Location Action Condition Emotion
So basically if you are formimg a sentance and you need to know which form to use; this is a key.
Not “en”, but “son” as in “Ellos son doctores.”
but we use ''?de donde eres?'' for asking a location....??? not use ?de donde estas? for where are you from........
De dónde eres isn't location, it's residence. Does that help?
“Where are you from? I am from California.” “Where are you? I am at the store.” No matter where I go I am always still from California so that uses the verb “ser” (“eres” is a form of ser), but where I am changes all the time so my current location uses “estar” (Estás is a form of estar).
The problem with that is the location of buildings is always with estar. Buildings are pretty permanent, so the metaphor starts to crumble :)
Yes, and the location of cities too, but buildings come and go and over the centuries even cities may be rebuilt. If an earthquake comes along and completely destroys California and it no longer has a location, I will still be from California. Where you are from happened at a certain time, in my case I was born there. It is a part of my identity. Identity always uses “ser”.
ESTOY en la fiesta de cumpeaños de mi abuelo. When they ask: "Donde ESTÁS?" SOY de América. When they ask: "De dónde ERES?"
Está is saying where something is while "Es" is saying that "something is". Not sure if you will understand because it is a bit tricky but just pay attention to how and when both words are used(:
Location is always está, because location can change. Es is used for more permenant situations.
I was aware of the "permanent" rule, but thought that a hospital's location would be regarded as permanent!
It wasn't always there. Something could happen and it could be rebuilt in a different place. Even cities and countries use "estar", I guess they rise and fall over millenia.
Really that "permanent" idea is extremely misleading because "ser" is used for planned event locations.
Seriously, it is better to memorize that ser is for innate qualities or professions or nationality, identity, for existence and ownership, to tell time, for the passive voice and for impersonal statements, as well as for planned events, and estar for emotions or changing qualities, states or conditions, locations and to form certain tenses.
Estar comes from the Latin stare, to stand. That's why it's used for location, it's where a building stands. Stare was also used in Late Latin for status, so temporary states. All related words.
That depends on the exercise that you had. If you had the listen to Spanish and write it down that would be in Spanish. You may have the translate English to Spanish or translate Spanish to English.
I put "Where is the ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ hospital?" and it marked me wrong! REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
Could it be "Donde esta la hospital"? Because I thought el meant "him" or "his"
No, “el” is “the” for masculine singular nouns and “la” is “the” for feminine singular nouns, “los” is “the” for plural masculine nouns and “las” is “the” for plural feminine nouns. Everything is masculine or feminine in Spanish. The Spanish word for hospital is masculine, so it must be “el hospital”.
The pronoun “he” is “él” with an accent and this form is also used for “him” as the object of a preposition, but “him” as a direct object is “lo” and “him” as an indirect object is “le”. “Su” and “Suyo” can mean “his” and you can also indicate “his” by using “de él”.
So, how do you know if a noun is masculine or feminine: https://www.thoughtco.com/noun-masculine-or-feminine-spanish-3079270
"El" is "The"
And "Él" is "He"
You are confused because of the stroke on the "e".
¿Dónde está el hospital? is --- Where is the hospital
Él está en el hospital. --- He is in the hospital.
Do you now undersxtand?
Estás means "you are". You need está, he/she/it is.
Does that help?
I think that the confusion is that sometimes “está” is for “usted” which also means “you are”, but not for this one in which the subject is “el hospital”.
Está also means "is". Using the word "usted" makes it looks like you are saying "You is" while using "tú" in "tú estás" makes it look like you are saying "you are". Although "You is" isn't grammatically correct, but it sounds more formal. The plural of "usted está" is "ustedes están" (you are).
Do you understand it slightly better? :)
“Usted” comes from an old form of addressing noblemen and royalty as “your mercy” or “vuestra merced”, because you would not directly address your superiors in those days. As one might have said back when, “Is your majesty pleased with.....?”
It just marked wrong the correct answer... the only difference is that i didnt put a question mark. is that really the reason to fail?
I cannot verify unless you copy your answer here and verify which exercise you had. For example, multiple choice can have more than one answer and all correct answers must be chosen. If you listen to Spanish then you must write what you hear in Spanish. You can take a screenshot when it is not accepted to verify everything.
Isn't this an irregular noun then, since it's "el hospital" instead of " la hospital"?
It is simply a masculine noun; only feminine nouns use “la”. I guess that it is less easy to figure out the words that don’t end in -o or -a. You can always look a word up in the dictionary. http://www.wordreference.com/es/en/translation.asp?spen=hospital
The word came from Latin through French to English and it is masculine in French also.