"The tradition is rather young in Germany."

Translation:In Deutschland ist die Tradition noch eher jung.

March 26, 2013

This discussion is locked.


Where did the "noch" come from, and why is it essential?

[deactivated user]

    The correct answer would be:

    "Die Tradition ist ziemlich jung in Deutschland."

    (Actually it should be: "Diese...)

    Now I see the English sentence is actually not good either. It should be "This tradition" Because if someone speaks about a tradition/custom he means a particular one!

    Well, it has been marked wrong, but I don't care. I know that I am right, so what.

    To your question:

    This is a different construction of the sentence which is also correct.

    They shift the emphasis to the adverbial part of the sentence "rather young" that's fine.

    "noch eher" is actually the same as "ziemlich" = rather whereas the "noch" gives the "eher" an extra touch of uncertainty and they belong together in this case.

    Hope that helps a bit.


    Thank you. I hadn't thought to look for "noch eher" as a phrase, but, thus prompted, found it at http://www.linguee.de/deutsch-englisch/uebersetzung/noch+eher.html Interesting.

    As for "the" vs. "this" - In English, I believe "the tradition" is just fine, because you're referring to a particular tradition - you're not even considering any others. It's just like referring to "the dog" - yes, there are other dogs in the world, but only one in the situation you're considering.

    [deactivated user]

      It's all about context, but you are right "the tradition" is fine in most cases.

      Thanks, the link is awesome. Very good explanation!


      Thanks for clearing this up. "Eher" is a new one on me. :)

      Learn German in just 5 minutes a day. For free.