"There are not many restaurants around the hotel."

Translation:酒店的周围没有很多饭馆。

August 15, 2018

4 Comments


https://www.duolingo.com/Phxstick

Why is the 的 necessary between 酒店 and 周围, but can be omitted between 家 and 周围 in the sentence 我的家周围有很多树?

August 15, 2018

https://www.duolingo.com/King184867

I am Chinese. “的” is to point out the possession, just like ('s) in English,

e.g. Wang's book - 王的書, Li's telephone - 李的電話。

Make a one to one translation:

酒店 - 的- 週圍 = hotel - 's - around

Of course it's not a structure of English, therefore we say "around the hotel".

For the example you mentioned "我的家周围有很多树". Imagine an example in English: Your mother has a private doctor. And the doctor has a daughter. Then when you mention the daughter, you won’t say “My mother’s private doctor’s daughter”. You will say “my mother private doctor’s daughter” (it may not be a proper English structure, but I just want to show you how the above Chinese sentence similar to it.)

Therefore, 我的家周围有很多树 or 我的家的周围有很多树 are not wrong. But 我的家的周围有很多树 is not so native. Just like “My mother’s private doctor’s daughter”.

Hope it can help you.

August 19, 2018

https://www.duolingo.com/Phxstick

Thanks for the reply. So if I were to formulate a general rule, would it be correct to say that only the first 的 is kept in case of nested possessives? E.g. if I extend your example sentence a bit and nest three posessives: "My mother’s doctor’s daughter's house", would the most natural Chinese translation omit 的 twice like 我妈妈的医生女儿家 ?

August 19, 2018

https://www.duolingo.com/Zfe10

酒店周围没有很多饭馆。is correct as well, i think that 的 is not necessary

August 30, 2018
Learn Chinese in just 5 minutes a day. For free.