1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: Indonesian
  4. >
  5. "Itu pensil dia."

"Itu pensil dia."

Translation:That is his pencil.

August 16, 2018



What is the difference in meaning of: 'that is his pencil' and 'that pencil is his'?


Itu pensil dia = That is his pencil

(itu) is the first word and is not after a noun so it goes first (pensil dia) is a noun-possessive connection and so is always said together (and usually backwards).

Pensil itu miliknya = That pencil is his

(Pensil itu dia) is a noun-adjective-possessive and is said together and also usually said backwards (Gaun merah saya = my red dress).

This doesn't translate well with determinatives ( e.g. the, that, this) For example "Pensil itu miliknya" read last to first is close to "He [owns] that pencil".

I have owns in square quotes because the literal translation would be "He belongs to that pensil", but it's just that it doesn't translate grammatically.


Would you say that there is a meaningful distinction between the two in Indonesian?

I ask because there is none in English, so perhaps the significance is only in one direction (English->Indonesian), but I do not know enough Indonesian to know.

Thank you for the explanation! :D


There is no real distinction but understanding it will help you understand Indonesian speakers.

Plus there may be no real difference here but there are plenty of times where English sentences that seem to be pretty much the same have precedence.

To match the speaking style of the person you're talking to.

To follow up a point.

To repeat similar sentences, or to make sentences more unique.


Bravo Sierra! You are full of it.


There is no difference


In English, there is no difference. The meaning is the same.


When do you attach "nya" to a noun and when do you use "dia"?


Doesn't matter which one to use. It has the same meaning


You use dia or -nya when it is informal and beliau (which will come later) as formal


Then entry before this marked me wrong when I wrote "itu pensil dia". The suggestion was to write "itu pensilnya". I AM CONFUSED!!


Why don't they allow that's instead of 'that is'?


These phrases are the exact same thing


Same as " That pencil is his. "


Día isn't for him and her? Why is "that is her pencil" not correct?

[deactivated user]

    Is it correct to say: pensil itu dia. ?

    Learn Indonesian in just 5 minutes a day. For free.