"It is the prize for being a good man."

Translation:Es el premio por ser un buen hombre.

March 29, 2013

This discussion is locked.


what is the difference btw "por" and "para"?


There are 27+ ways you can use "por" and about 13+ ways you can use "para". The simplest approach is to learn the 4 common cases for "para" and use "por" if none of those cases fit. Here is a video on it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_cBJoq479NM My guess either showing "gratitude" or "exchange" is why "por" is used here.


million thanks!:)


A simple rule, which covers this case, is that "para" is used to indicate who something is for, in the sense of receiving in the future, and that "por" is used to indicate what event in the past something is a result of. So, for example, we might say "eso es el premio para él por ser un buen hombre" for "that is the prize for him for being a good man". This rule doesn't cover all uses of course.


be careful, though. If for example my friend Elena is sick and asks me to substitute for her (in exchange) it will be por Elena, not para; but if I am working for Elena's Dad, that would be para!


Well, if we ignore the "future" and "past" parts of the rule, we can think of your example as follows: the event (here in the future) is Elena's absence. We are substituting in response to that event, so we use "por". So, e.g. "voy a sustituir por Elena para la escuela": the school is receiving our action and so we use "para" with "la escuela" (I expect something like "en" for "para" would be better here, but I want to use both "por" and "para" to illustrate the rule again).


Es el premio por siendo un buen hombre.

Rejected, but not reported. Someone tell me why it's wrong, please.


use the infinitive verb form after a preposition.


Why not "es el premio para estar un hombre bueno" ?


Characteristics are usually stated with "ser".


Why is bueno wrong?

Learn Spanish in just 5 minutes a day. For free.