"तूने आम नहीं खाये।"
Translation:You did not eat the mangoes.
27 CommentsThis discussion is locked.
1602
One should be very careful while using तूने or तूas it should only be used in your closed friend circle of the same age group or if the other person is younger than you.
If you use it with strangers or in formal setting, you will offend the other person and embarras those around you.
However, as long as you are in the novice stage, I don't think people will mind, they will certainly be shocked though
- 613
That's what I wanted to say, it's an informal word used with friends and some people younger than you. It shouldn't be used to elders.
- 1464
Although in Hindi mango is plural in the sentence, wouldn't 'you did not eat mango?' be acceptable - much as we talk about 'fruit' rather than 'fruits' when speaking generally.
It should have been accepted but unfortunately duolingo still doesn't accept it.
I really wish duolingo would use आप and तुम over तु as I have seen many many native speakers say to avoid saying तु to avoid offending or being rude to people. It feels like duo is teaching us to sound rude in Hindi.
What is तूने? I mean the translation makes it obvious it means 'you', but why is ने added to it? Why not simply तू? Is it because of the past tense somehow? Dang I wish these later lessons had notes!! Thanks for any reply :)
- 1464
Yes, it is because of the past tense and is a particle added to the subject to indicate the past for transitive verbs - those that take an object - as far as my understanding goes. That said, it would be helpful it a native speaker would enlarge on this and provide some clear examples, wouldn't it?
Found this thanks to another comment: http://www.learning-hindi.com/post/2392152114/lesson-83-the-past-tense-for-transitive-verbs
Does anyone know if there is an advanced duo lingo which helps with compound verbs and irregular verbs? Thank you.
- 1464
That is a good question. The best I have come up with is to 'learn English' by registering as a Hindi speaker in Duolingo. The course is more developed than the present one. Whatever else it will add to your perspective and insights in terms of being a HIndi speaker. The downside is that you will hear more English than Hindi. Whatever else keep at it. It is quite a mind expanding adventure:-)
- 574
I found this helpful (also Part 2, lesson 114):
https://www.learning-hindi.com/post/6113164275/lesson-113-compound-verbs-part-1
Could someone kindly explain why 'You did not eat the mango' is incorrect. Thank you.
- 2783
For Past Tense sentences with Transitive verbs the verb agrees with the object of the sentence and not, as we’ve been used to so far, the subject.
http://www.learning-hindi.com/post/2392152114/lesson-83-the-past-tense-for-transitive-verbs
- 1464
That is a cross cultural way of thinking about it. When a word is associated with a preposition - in this case, the subject in an English sentence - it becomes a 'circumstance' such that, the 'object' in English then IS the subject of the sentence. Hence, the concordance makes perfect sense, doesn't it? Just enlarging on your point...
Olexsa, Thanks for the info. On a personal note, you must have 2 billion followers. Every time I try to click on your profile, my app freezes : )
These past tense lessons are not well conceived. They are playing fast and loose with the English definite article. Sometimes it is used in the Duolingo translations and sometimes not, with no context for choosing. Well and good, but sometimes it is accepted in the Hindi translation and sometimes not, with no context for choosing. I just have to memorize Duolingo's required answer blindly, as it teaches me nothing about making the choice.
Sorry friends, l'm a starter in Hindi language but I don't know what to start with to speak fluently.And also which source should I use in order not to spend any money. We also don't have any books to study Hindi grammer in our city. Got any ideas?
This is a statement I will never agree with. Alphonsos rule supreme!
