"Bilasáana daosą́ʼ"

Translation:All of you eat apples

November 2, 2018

This discussion is locked.


I wrote "eat this apple" which was actually the suggestion after I checked it, and it stated that I was wrong. Could someone please fix either the suggestion, or the answer?

Thank you!


How can you tell the difference between them saying "Eat this apple" and "All of you eat apples"? I also used the suggested "You all eat apples" and that was incorrect as well. Could someone explain why? Thanks.

[deactivated user]

    headdesks in frustration The course creators do realize that Navajo doesn't distinguish noun plurality, and that Navajo doesn't have any articles, right? They should accept "an apple/the apple/the apples" as English translations. Reported.


    How can I distinguish if daosá is eat this or all of you eat....it's as confusing as Russian


    shoutout to all you apple-eaters out there


    I put "All of you eat an apple" Shouldn't this be correct, too?

    Please explain...


    Question: Is that a command? or an observation?


    It's both. Regular imperfective mode (≈present) can be used for imperative in the second persons. Context is key there. Navajo doesn't have a proper imperative tense so it makes do with imperfective or future.


    Perhaps it's like the pushy Italian or Macedonian grandmother who demands that everyone eat more? From my experience with a cousin's grandmother, that was all she could say...


    Why is "[food] daosą́ʼ" an observation here and a command in some entries?


    If this can be both the present tense (descriptive -- all of you eat apples) as well as the imperative (command -- Eat the apples), then the possible correct answers should reflect that or the context should be given so we can figure out the right answer!


    Accepts "Eat this apple" but not "Eat an apple"


    Seems theyʼve changed to All of you eat apples.


    Didn't accept Eat this Apple for me


    There is a lack of clues to let you know you are addressing a group and the point of the exercise is to make sure that you are using the plural of "you."

    Learn Navajo in just 5 minutes a day. For free.