"How much tea do you drink?"

Translation:तू कितनी चाय पीता है?

November 5, 2018

This discussion is locked.


Why is the female version of 'how much' used?


When the object is female. Here it is चाय which is female.


The confusion is because in the "lightbulb" to the Numbers lesson, it states that adverbs do not change form by sex or number, yet कितना is an adverb. More specifically, in the English Wiktionary कितना is classified as an adverb, yet the English "how much" is broken down into either determiner or adverb, depending on use. So, when used to modify a verb, then "how much" is an adverb, and this agrees with the lesson here that कितना must not change with verbs and that adverbs don't decline (change form).

This gets a little trickier when "how much" is a determiner. "How much cheese is there?" uses it in conjunction with a noun, so here everything is clear — it would decline in Hindi, exactly as in this example with "tea". Wiktionary also gives the examples "How much is left in the fridge?" and "How much is it?" under "Determiner", though one could assume "how much" modifies "is" here and is therefore an adverb. This is where it gets tricky in drawing parallels to Hindi. I wonder how a sentence like "How much is left in the fridge?", where there is no explicitly stated object, would translate in Hindi.

Really, I hate determiners. They are a headache in German too, where sometimes "ihr" is classified as a determiner, sometimes as a pronoun.


A lot of confusion in your explaination


My confusion is why female for "how much" but male for "drink"


that's because they're unrelated. just like in most languages, "how much" agrees with the object (the tea) while the verb "drink" agrees w/the subject (the drinker)


Tum kinti chai pete ho is correct !!! Answer given above is wrong


Is "kitnee chae tu pita hae" also correct?


The normal word order in Hindi is subject-object-verb (and this doesn't change for questions, unlike English). You've used the order object-subject-verb.

So I don't think that's correct, but hopefully a native Hindi speaker can answer.


Why is kitni before the chai? I thought the question is always near the verb


If the question word relates to the verb, it goes before the verb.
Here the question word relates to the noun, so goes just before the noun—with the appropriate ending.


it should NOT be कितनी right? because HE is used


Shouldn't it be tu ho?


no. it's tu hai, tum ho


तू is manner less but तुम is right


Water is masculine and tea is feminine!!! Who defined these and how?

Learn Hindi in just 5 minutes a day. For free.