"हवा चलती है ।"

Translation: The wind blows.

[shukladhaivat17]

The air blows. Why wrong?

[vinay92]

You are right that Hindi doesn't make much of a distinction between 'air' and 'wind'. You could say 'हवा बहती है' to mean 'the air flows'.

[zeebo7]

This isn't correct English.

[hollyxyzzy]

It's not how English speakers would say it, but I can't say it's wrong.

[chris.beaton3]

So in Hindi, are you literally saying "the wind walks" to convey when it is moving?

[vinay92]

चलना is not just 'walk'. It can have a general meaning of 'move'. For example, you'd say 'गाड़ी चल रही है' for 'The car is moving', 'क्या तुम मेरे साथ सिनेमा चलोगी' for 'Will you come to the movies with me', 'समय बहुत तेज़ चल रहा है' for 'Time is moving very fast' etc.

In fact, if it's not clear that it means 'walk' in a particular context, you need to specify 'पैदल चलना' - 'move by foot'. For example, 'जूलिया की दादी 5 किलोमीटर पैदल चलकर स्कूल जाती थीं' (Julia's grandmother used to go to school by walking 5km)

[ErwinRooij]

I see. I thought चल was walking because of earlier examples. Now it's clear to me why "the wind walks" was marked incorrect

[mohammedsiraj.ww]

Yes,I also had the same question

[Kookkannan]

In Hindi, wind walks. In English, wind blows. In Tamil, wind beats.

[DanielKnow8]

Slightly disappointed "the air moves" isnt accepted

[Roger423959]

The air blows should be accepted

[Linus130441]

Shoutout to everyone who answered "The air walks"