- Forum >
- Topic: German >
- "That is why I am mad at him."
"That is why I am mad at him."
Translation:Deshalb bin ich sauer auf ihn.
49 Comments
wütend and sauer are synonyms here, just as well as Deshalb and Darum. I suggest adding "Deshalb (or Darum) bin ich wütend auf ihn" to the correct solutions.
Why is auf taking the accusative here? It doesn't make a lot of sense.. is there some way of making sense into it, or is it just one of those things you need to memorize? Sauer sein auf acc.?
why is ihn accusative? from what I've learned, auf is a two way preposition and when there is no motion, it becomes dative. Is this overridden by the fact that "ihn" (him) is the direct object?
I think it is because 'auf' does NOT refer to LOCATION in this circumstance. Because of that, it takes accusative.
Does anyone know of a good resource to know which words count as a position in the sentence? I know the rule of keeping the verb in the second position, but every now and then I'll come across a word that exists outside the sentence where you'd normally think it takes the first position...
I really like the Dartmouth German grammer site. Here's the word order section: http://www.dartmouth.edu/~deutsch/Grammatik/WordOrder/WordOrder.html
I suspect that would imply you and he are both mad together, not at anything in particular.
I can't say for sure, but I believe that would mean you're describing your method of delivering your anger. Like "Via the internet, I am mad at him" It's not so much a reason you're giving.
It does make sense, but I believe that few sentences earlier "dadurch" was used as "therefore", so I'm slightly confused.
According to Duden, dadurch and darum are synonyms:
1565
Wouldn't it be more grammatically correct to say "Deshalb bin ich (böse/wütend) auf ihn"? This translates to "That is why I am peeved at him" - a synonym, but not the same.
Daher and deshalb has been interchangeable on some if not many DL phrases. In this particular instance "daher" is not accepted. Have somebody any idea why? please see below before commenting: https://www.dict.cc/?s=That+is+why
- 561
I wrote "Daher bin ich sauer auf ihn" and wasn't accepted, should I report it, if not why?
olimo is right. ""Das ist weil" would mean something like "That is because" if you translate it back to English. "darum" and "deshalb" are both correct. You'll also need to take care of the prepositions here, you cannot say "an ihnen". In German, you use "wütend" with the preposition "auf", so it would be "wütend auf ihn". You can trust me, even if I only have 8 levels of German here in duolingo - I am a German native speaker, I'm originally only here to learn Spanish ;) But I know the pain of trying to figure out which prepositions to use, we Germans have the same problem with the English ones. :)
I always thought wütend meant furious - much stronger than sauer. Have I got that wrong?
I don't think "Das ist weil" will work for "That is why". There are "deshalb" or "darum" for that.
The rule is "the verb should always come second". So if there's an adverb at the start, or a clause before the sentence, you swap them round.
That's a generalisation, but it should get you started. Conjunctions don't count, for instance. So it would still be, "Aber ich bin sauer auf ihn."
Er is Nominative, Ihn is Accusative, Ihm is Dative.
Duo explains about Accusative and Dative pronouns if you need help.
I don't know if it is the same for MTVVV, but my problem is that 'auf' usually takes dative. Do you know why it is accusative here? Thanks
If it means "on", "auf" takes dative. If it means "onto", "auf" takes accusative.
I'm not sure if that's always true, but just remember that with dual prepositions, accusative means there's motion and dative means there's position.
Das ist auf dem Tisch = That is on the table
Stelle das auf den Tisch = Set that on/onto the table.
You're quite right, I'm sure I already knew that. Don't know why I asked this question, thank you though.
I always thought deshalb was "therefore" and deswegen was "that is why". Do they mean the same thing?
They are synonymous, yes, just like Warum, Wieso, Weshalb, and Weswegen. They all have very subtly different tones, though, so at worst you might sound less than native.
Well, yes; 'I'm cold, therefore I put on a jumper', or 'I'm cold, and that is why I put on a jumper'. Same thing really.
I see where you're coming from, but no, 'anger' is not a German word as far as I know, and you can't use the German word for 'anger' - 'Zorn' - with 'mit'. Personally, I would say 'Ich bin ihm böse', 'böse' is the best translation I know for 'angry'.
Why does this one have inverted word order and sogar sie hat ein Fahrrad, doesn't?
this should be corrected to accept 'boese " as correct word for mad (sauer)
StenevGill - both question should be corrected to accept boese. Thank you.
program is STILL not accepting boese as correct answer! Please correct so that I may advance.
Three weeks ago Boese was accepted as correct translation for mad. now it will not accept. please correct
