"This is not milk."

Translation:ʻAʻole kēia he waiū.

February 12, 2019

This discussion is locked.


ʻAʻole he waiū kēia should be accepted. the equational clauses should be interchangeable.


Why is "he" needed in this sentence?


"Milk" is a countable noun in Hawaiian, whereas it's uncountable in English. "Chair", for example, is countable. This is why we say "This is not milk.", but also "This is not a chair." So, because "milk" is countable in Hawaiian you basically need to say "This is not a milk" when translating this sentence into Hawaiian :)


Hmm... I'm not an expert Hawaiian speaker, but I suspect a better explanation is that you always use 'he' for the indefinite as opposed to ke/ka for the definite whether or not a noun is a count noun. Hopefully someone who knows better will way into this conversation about this point.


So how would you translate "Ua inu 'o ia i 'ekolu waiū" into English?


She drank three milks??


But isn't "a milk" ka waiū? Why is ka wrong here? I'm still not following the logic.


If you say 'this is something', he is always needed in hawaiian, as it seems. He wai keia (li. This is a water) not ka wai keia.


I think "ka" is a definite article meaning "the" rather than an indefinite article meaning "a/an."


If it's not milk then what is it


That's in another lesson.


Does anyone know why "'A'ole he waiū kēia" is not correct?


In all the examples Iu have seen, 'a'ole is followed only by pronouns.

'a'ole 'o ia 'ai = he doesn't eat but 'a'ole 'ai 'o Kawika (not 'a'ole 'o kawika 'ai)

If keia is considered a pronoun and obeys this rule, then perhaps that's the reason why keia MUST follow 'a'ole


Thatʻs what I was thinking too. It seems that when thereʻs negation with ʻaʻole itʻs followed by the subject if that subject is a pronoun or a demonstrative pronoun.


Guess we need to see "water is not coffee" in Hawaiian to know :)


Wow, if that's true Zabrunga that would answer a LOT of questions I've had! Hope an expert confirms or denies!! Meanwhile I'll use your rule of lima nui (thumb :) ).


Since spelling is the same the only thing that is off are the marks or punctation which my phone does not have. I think should count as correct if words match

Learn Hawaiian in just 5 minutes a day. For free.