"An orange is a fruit."

Translation:संतरा एक फल होता है।

April 12, 2019

This discussion is locked.


संतरा एक फल है is this not right


Use होना with universal truths. An orange is always a fruit. If you were instead talking about the color of a flower, for example, then you could say इस फूल का रंग नीला है, "This flower's color is blue." You exclude होना because another flower could be a different color.


I answered this only and it was right....


When should we use होता, and होते, होती?


Other reply addressed their gender and plurality, but in case you meant when to use any of them - in the habitual aspect. I.e. something that is generally true, not just true at the moment or for a specific instance.

Note that it's a property of grammar, not of vocabulary or logic, so you can say the same sentence (modulo grammar changes) in the habitual or other aspect, and have it be valid in each case.


"Hota" is for anything masculine,"hoti" is for anything feminine and "hotay" is for plurals..


Forgive because I cant type hindi at the moment! Hota is used for male nouns. Hote is used for respect or for plural. Hoti is used for female nouns. As time will pass and when you will practise soon you would be able to distinguish them rapidly


Why not use एक twice?


The way I understand it, (native speakers please correct if I'm wrong!) is that एक gives much more emphasis to singularity than 'an', it's closer to 'one' even when not used as a number.

So, just as in English, saying 'one orange' is a fruit makes the listener think 'what about the others?'

Especially in this sentence with होता, the combination to me starts to sound like a children's story: 'there was one orange, different to all the others, he was a fruit'!


Male: होता-होना। Female: होती-होनी। Hō-tā hō-nā hō-tī hō-nī

Learn Hindi in just 5 minutes a day. For free.